Abstract:Significance The 5/2 fractional quantum Hall state has captured the fascination of the scientific and nonscientific community, because of proposals to use it for quantum computation. These proposals have been based on the premise that the quasiparticles in this state have non-Abelian statistics. Experiments supporting both Abelian 5/2 state and non-Abelian 5/2 state have been reported, and no consensus has been reached. Using measurements of tunneling between edge states, we suggest that both the Abelian and non-Abelian states can be stable in the same device but under different conditions. Our discovery resolves the inconsistencies between existing experiments. More importantly, the knowledge of the competition between ground states is important for maintaining non-Abelian statistics in application to topological quantum computation. Some theories predict that the filling factor 5/2 fractional quantum Hall state can exhibit non-Abelian statistics, which makes it a candidate for fault-tolerant topological quantum computation. Although the non-Abelian Pfaffian state and its particle-hole conjugate, the anti-Pfaffian state, are the most plausible wave functions for the 5/2 state, there are a number of alternatives with either Abelian or non-Abelian statistics. Recent experiments suggest that the tunneling exponents are more consistent with an Abelian state rather than a non-Abelian state. Here, we present edge-current–tunneling experiments in geometrically confined quantum point contacts, which indicate that Abelian and non-Abelian states compete at filling factor 5/2. Our results are consistent with a transition from an Abelian state to a non-Abelian state in a single quantum point contact when the confinement is tuned. Our observation suggests that there is an intrinsic non-Abelian 5/2 ground state but that the appropriate confinement is necessary to maintain it. This observation is important not only for understanding the physics of the 5/2 state but also for the design of future topological quantum computation devices.

3/2 Fractional Quantum Hall Plateau in Confined Two-Dimensional Electron Gas

Superperiods in Interference of E/3 Laughlin Quasiparticles Encircling Filling 2/5 Fractional Quantum Hall Island

Anomalous Even Denominator Fractional Quantum Hall Plateaus in Confined Region

Anomalous quantized plateaus in two-dimensional electron gas with gate confinement

Ground State and Edge Excitations of A Quantum Hall Liquid at Filling Factor 2/3

A ug 2 01 6 Fractional Quantum Hall Bilayers at Half-Filling : Tunneli ng-driven Non-Abelian Phase

Fractional Quantum Hall Effect at Ν = 5/2: Ground States, Non-Abelian Quasiholes, and Edge Modes in a Microscopic Model

Striped Quantum Hall State in A Half-filled Landau Level

Fractional Quantum Hall Bilayers at Half-Filling: Tunneling-driven Non-Abelian Phase

Fractional Quantum Hall States with Gapped Boundaries in an Extreme Lattice Limit

Fractional Quantum Hall States In Two-Dimensional Electron Systems With Anisotropic Interactions

Competing Nu=5/2 Fractional Quantum Hall States In Confined Geometry

Recent Experimental Progress of Fractional Quantum Hall Effect: 5/2 Filling State and Graphene

Non-Abelian fractional quantum Hall states at filling factor 3/4

Discovery of Competing 5/2 Fractional Quantum Hall States

Fractional Quantum Hall State at Filling Factor $ν=1/4$ in Ultra-High-Quality GaAs 2D Hole Systems

From Fractional Chern Insulators To Abelian And Non-Abelian Fractional Quantum Hall States: Adiabatic Continuity And Orbital Entanglement Spectrum

Highly-Anisotropic Even-Denominator Fractional Quantum Hall State in an Orbitally-Coupled Half-Filled Landau Level

Half-quantized Hall Plateaus in the Confined Geometry of Graphene

Competing ν = 5/2 fractional quantum Hall states in confined geometry.

Integer and Fractional Quantum Hall Effect in Two-Terminal Measurements on Suspended Graphene