Abstract:In a recent report on the patterns of tree species richness in eastern and western North America, Marks et al. (2016) claimed to have identified an operational indicator of environmental harshness (maximum tree height) and concluded that environmental stressors that limit tree height also act as ecological filters on species richness. Marks et al. (2017) attributed the positive association between species richness and maximum tree height to both the direct effects of environmental harshness on species richness and the indirect effects of environmental harshness on species richness as mediated by maximum tree height. This finding overlooked the fact that many environmental stressors such as cyclonic disturbance affect tree height and tree species diversity in different directions. In a study of elevational patterns in Taiwan, Chi et al. (2015) reported sharply contrasting relationships between tree species diversity and canopy tree height in sites that were subject to tropical cyclone disturbance vs. those that were not. In the mountains of southeastern China beyond the reach of tropical cyclones, both tree species richness and canopy tree height decreased with increasing elevation (Zheng et al. 2004, Chi et al. 2015), supporting the harshness hypothesis (Marks et al. 2016, 2017). In contrast, in Taiwan, where tropical cyclones occur annually, tree species richness decreased but maximum tree height increased with increasing elevation, the opposite of the predictions of the harshness hypothesis (Fig. 1). We attributed the contrasting elevational patterns and associations between tree diversity and canopy tree height in Taiwan to topographic mediation of tropical cyclone disturbance. The shorter tree stature in lower elevations was attributed to more severe tropical cyclone damage (Chi et al. 2015). Although tropical cyclones limit tree height, tree mortality is very low, possibly a result of both evolutional and ecological responses of these forest ecosystems through the long-term interaction between cyclones and the forest ecosystems (Lin et al. 2011). As an example, multiple category three tropical cyclones on the Saffir-Simpson scale (Simpson and Riehl 1981) caused <2% tree mortality in low-elevation evergreen broadleaf forest in northeastern Taiwan in 1994, a record year of tropical cyclone frequency and intensity (Lin et al. 2011). However, taller trees were selectively killed and defoliation was severe, both of which contributed to the low stature of the forest even though the mean annual temperature (18°C) and precipitation (3800) mm are high (Lin et al. 2011). Cyclone disturbance limits vertical development of trees but does not lead to their elimination. Thus, more tropical cyclone disturbance at lower elevations overrides climatic controls on elevational patterns of tree height but does not change the elevational pattern of tree species richness. We suggest that there is an important difference between actual maximum tree height and potential maximum tree height in the presence of disturbance (e.g., tropical cyclone). Across an elevational gradient (700–3000 m) in Taiwan, we found that maximum tree height was not a good predictor of tree species alpha richness (i.e., richness of each plot; Fig. 2a), whereas components of environmental harshness, moisture index (Fig. 2b), and warmth index were (Fig. 2c). Moreover, the relationship between maximum tree height and either of the two components of environmental harshness was not significant (Fig. 2d, e). Such results challenge the fundamental assumption (i.e., factors that limit tree height also limit species richness and the effects are in the same direction) underlying the use of maximum tree height as a predictor of tree species richness in disturbance-prone regions. As such, our results of increasing canopy tree height and decreasing species diversity of trees along the 2300-m elevational gradient in central Taiwan (Chi et al. 2015) demonstrate that tree height is not a universal indicator of environmental harshness. The cumulative consequences of the components of environmental harshness may be different for richness and maximum tree height, especially in disturbance-mediated systems. In summary, we argue that tropical cyclones and maybe other types of disturbance (e.g., outbreak of insects that damage apical buds) could have different impacts on species richness and maximum tree height. Consequently, caution should be exercised when using maximum tree height as a useful surrogate of environmental harshness to predict large-scale patterns of tree species richness within ecoregions. We suggest that application of the surrogate be constrained to regions without frequent disturbances that affect tree height and tree species richness in different directions. This research was supported in part by grants from the National Science Council of Taiwan (98-2313-B-003-003, 99-2313-B-003-003, 100-2313-B-003-002). The authors have no conflict of interest. We thank Lienhuachi Research Center of Taiwan Forestry Research Institute, Auwanda National Forest Recreation Area, Highland Experimental Farm of National Taiwan University, and Endemic Species Research Institute of Taiwan for logistical support.

Tropical cyclones disrupt the relationship between tree height and species diversity: Comment

Typhoon Disturbance Mediates Elevational Patterns of Forest Structure, but not Species Diversity, in Humid Monsoon Asia

Long-term tropical cyclones activity shapes forest structure and reduces tree species diversity of U.S. temperate forests

Author Response for "non‐linear Thresholds in the Effects of Island Area on Functional Diversity in Woody Plant Communities"

Extreme Winter Storms Have Variable Effects on the Population Dynamics of Canopy Dominant Species in an Old-Growth Subtropical Forest

The Shift from Energy to Water Limitation in Local Canopy Height from Temperate to Tropical Forests in China

Elevational Patterns of Tree Species Richness and Forest Biomass on Two Subtropical Mountains in China

Intense light and conspecific density increase seedling mortality across age groups in a typhoon‐disturbed tropical forest

Damage to tropical forests caused by cyclones is driven by wind speed but mediated by topographical exposure and tree characteristics

Decoupling the Impact of Biodiversity and Environmental Factors on the Biomass and Biomass Growth of Trees in Subtropical Forests

Tree Species Richness Increases Spatial Variation but Not Overall Wood Decomposition

Forest Type and Height Are Important in Shaping the Altitudinal Change of Radial Growth Response to Climate Change

Effects of Light and Topography on Regeneration and Coexistence of Evergreen and Deciduous Tree Species in a Chinese Subtropical Forest

Topography Related Habitat Associations of Tree Species Traits, Composition and Diversity in a Chinese Tropical Forest

Disentangling Environmental Effects on the Tree Species Abundance Distribution and Richness in a Subtropical Forest

Direct and Indirect Effects of Climate on Richness Drive the Latitudinal Diversity Gradient in Forest Trees

Disturbance history, neighborhood crowding and soil conditions jointly shape tree growth in temperate forests

Latitudinal patterns in stabilizing density dependence of forest communities

Tall Bornean forests experience higher canopy disturbance rates than those in the eastern Amazon or Guiana shield

Tree richness increased biomass carbon sequestration and ecosystem stability of temperate forests in China: Interacted factors and implications

Multiscale predictors of small tree survival across a heterogeneous tropical landscape