Abstract:Bedload transport plays a vital role in shaping Earth’s environment by promoting the formation and growth of geological features of various scales, including ripples and dunes, deltas and fans, and laminations and cross-bedding. A key problem hampering our understanding of bedload-induced landscape evolution is the notoriously large variability commonly associated with measurements of bedload flux, even under controlled and highly idealized conditions in the laboratory, such as fully-developed, unidirectional open-channel flows over flat beds composed of grains of nearly uniform sizes. For example, two recent experimental studies report a nearly sixfold different nondimensionalized bedload flux at a comparable Shields number for spherical grains [1, 2]. The likely culprit is the immense difficulty experimentalists face in estimating the transport-driving bed shear stress. There is currently no universally accepted method of even determining the bed surface elevation in the presence of bedload transport, which is particularly problematic for shallow flows where small changes have a large effect. Neither is there agreement on how to account for the effects of sidewall friction, which become the stronger the smaller the width-to-depth ratio b/h of the open-channel flow. Standardly employed empirical sidewall corrections have arguably a greater resemblance to cooking recipes than to formal physically-derived methods. In addition to such experimental difficulties, there is the physical question of how grain shape, which usually is not controlled for in laboratory experiments, affects bedload flux. A recent prominently published study argued that grain shape is the predominant reason for bedload flux variability and put forward a semi-empirical, analytical bedload transport model to account for it [1]. Here, we compile data from existing experiments and existing and new DNS-DEM, LES-DEM, and RANS-DEM numerical simulations of turbulent bedload transport of shape-controlled grains, in which b/h varies between 0.1 and infinity (periodic boundary conditions in simulations). After employing a non-empirical sidewall correction, which we derived from the phenomenological theory of turbulence, and a granular-physics-based method to determine the bed surface elevation, all data for spherical grains of sufficient size collapse onto a single curve, resolving the experimental problem of bed shear stress determination. Furthermore, the combined data for spherical and non-spherical grains are in strong disagreement with the model of Ref. [1] but support our alternative analytical bedload model across grain shapes, bed slopes, flow strengths, and channel widths. [1] Deal et al., Nature 613, 298 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-022-05564-6 [2] Ni & Capart, Geophysical Research Letters 45, 7000 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1029/2018GL07757

Effect of Grain Sorting on Gravel Bed River Evolution Subject to Cycled Hydrographs: Bed Load Sheets and Breakdown of the Hydrograph Boundary Layer

Resolving Bedload Flux Variability

Gravel‐bed River Evolution in Earthquake‐prone Regions Subject to Cycled Hydrographs and Repeated Sediment Pulses

Graded bed load transport in sediment supply limited channels under unsteady flow hydrographs

Numerical Investigation on the Adaptation of Dam-Break Flow-Induced Bed Load Transport to the Capacity Regime over a Sloping Bed

Autogenic Formation of Bimodal Grain Size Distributions in Rivers and Its Contribution to Gravel-Sand Transitions

Entrainment and Turbulence Characteristics of Continuous-Flux Release Gravity Current over Rough Beds

Grain Size-Specific Engelund-Hansen Type Relation for Bed Material Load in Sand-Bed Rivers, with Application to the Mississippi River

Evolution of Gravel Surfaces in a Sediment‐recirculating Flume

Entrainment, motion and deposition of coarse particles transported by water over a sloping mobile bed

Hysteretic Implications for Graded Bed Load Sediment Transport in Symmetrical Hydrograph Flows

River Morphological Evolution In Earthquake-Hit Region: Effects Of Floods And Pulsed Sediment Supply

Sediment supply and the development of the coarse surface layer in gravel-bedded rivers

The Advective‐Diffusive Morphodynamics of Mixed Bedrock‐Alluvial Rivers Subjected to Spatiotemporally Varying Sediment Supply

Bed Texture and Topographic Response to Increased Sediment Supply: The Sand Bed Case

Experimental Study on the Riverbed Coarsening Process and Changes in the Flow Structure and Resistance in the Gravel Riverbed Downstream of Dams

Self-adjustment Mechanism of Bed Structures under Hydrology and Sediment Regimes

The spatial distribution of coarse surface grains and the stability of gravel river beds

Numerical Model for Sediment Transport and Bed Degradation in the Yangtze River Channel Downstream of Three Gorges Reservoir

Extended Engelund–Hansen Type Sediment Transport Relation for Mixtures Based on the Sand-Silt-bed Lower Yellow River, China

On the process of fine sediment infiltration into static gravel bed: A CFD–DEM modelling perspective