Specification Error, Estimation Risk, And Conditional Portfolio Rules

Murray Carlson,David A. Chapman,Ron Kaniel,Hong Yan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/irfi.12110
2017-01-01
International Review of Finance
Abstract:In characterizing the data-generating process for excess returns, an investor faces both parameter uncertainty (or "estimation risk") and specification error. We examine the trade-off between these two effects, in the context of an optimal consumption/portfolio decision problem, by considering a minimal extension of the standard assumption of a linear vector autoregression for excess returns. The key additional assumption in our data-generating process is a positive linear relationship between market volatility and lagged market dividend yields. This simple specification is consistent with a long sample of U.S. data. We show that volatility adjusted rules are substantially less sensitive to variation in dividend yields, and volatility-related specification error is economically significant - even when the decisions are based on sample estimates from data sets of a realistic size.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?