Energy and Cardiopulmonary Cost of Carrying Hydration Gear During Running

Laura A. Zdziarski,Kyle Fallgatter,Trevor Leavitt,Wasser G. Joseph,Cong Chen,JoAnna I. McClelland,Kevin R. Vincent,Daniel C. Herman,Marybeth Horordyski,Jason L. Zaremski,Heather K. Vincent
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1249/01.mss.0000486098.68417.58
2016-01-01
Abstract:PURPOSE:It is not yet clear how the use of different hydration gear impacts cardiopulmonary responses and energy cost in healthy runners. The purpose of this study was to determine comparative effects of carrying different hydration gear compared to no gear on cardiopulmonary responses and energy cost during level running. METHODS:This was a crossover study design using healthy young runners (N=33; 28.0±6.6 yr, 1.73m, 68.4 kg, 56% men). Each participant completed four, 5-minute conditions on a level grade during one testing session at self-selected speed: 1) no gear, control (CON), 2) full-water bottle (FULL, 454g), 3) half-full-water bottle (HALF, 227g), and 4) belt (BELT, Amphipod RunLite, 676g) with two full water bottles. Condition testing order was randomized. A portable gas analyzer and heart rate monitor collected minute ventilation (Ve), rate of oxygen use (VO2), non-protein respiratory quotient (RQ), energy cost and heart rate (HR). RESULTS:The HALF condition generated the highest Ve compared to CON (78.4±23.3 L/min vs 65.0±22.0 L/min; p=.045). Average HR values were highest in BELT condition compared to HALF, FULL and CON (157bpm vs 151bpm, 151bpm and 143bpm, respectively; p=.029). RQ values and energy cost were not significantly different among the four conditions. CONCLUSIONS:Running with various hydration gear differentially increases the ventilatory or cardiac demand compared to CON. The findings suggest that runners may make adjustments to muscle activation patterns and movement strategies to maintain similar energy cost and fuel use among the four different conditions in the short-term. Additional studies using electromyographic techniques and motion analysis could be used to test these hypotheses.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?