Comparison of Treatment Styles for Depression Between Psychiatrists and Non- Psychiatrists in General Hospitals
陆峥,朱俊娟,蔡军,李玉珊,施慎逊,史以珏,王崇顺,蒋有倩,季建林,朱荣申,韩宏毅,丁素菊
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-6729.2009.06.003
2009-01-01
Abstract:Objective:By comparing the ability of coping with depressive disorders and evaluating the different therapeutic pattern between psychiatrists and non-psychiatrists in psychiatric clinics of general hospitals,the study is aimed to provide data for improving mental health service in general hospitals.Methods:The subjeds were 297 depressive patients consulting psychiatric clinics from 9 general hospitals in Shanghai,and assessed with the Hamilton Depression Rating Scale(HAMD),Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale(HAMA),self-made questionnaires in the first interview,two-,four-,eight-and twelve-week flow-up interviews to evaluate therapeutic effects.Results:According to the HAMD score reduction rate,there was great difference between psychiatrists treated group and non-psychiatrists treated group for the curative effect on the depression after 8-week and 12-week treatment(after 8-week:in psychiatrists treated group,the response rate was 56%,and the remission rate was 43%; in non-psychiatrists treated group,the response rate was 66%,and the remission rate was 20%,P0.001; after 12-week:in psychiatrists treated group,the response rate was 12%,and the remission rate was 88%; in non-psychiatrists treated group,the response rate was 38%,and the remission rate was 54%,P0.001).There was significantly statistical difference in HAMD total score reduction rate and some factors score reduction rate between the two groups after 2-,4-,8-and 12-week treatment.In patients prescribed with SSRIs antidepressants,12.7% were treated for less than 12 weeks in non-psychiatrists group,while only 2% in psychiatrists group(P0.001).The proportion of reducing medication was 24.5% in non-psychiatrists group,while only 6% in psychiatrists group(P0.001).There were statistical differences between the two groups in the patients' evaluation about side-effect,curative effect,whether to be willing to accept medication for long time or not in the 12-week follow-up(P0.05).In psychiatrists group 62% patients thought that the side-effect of antidepressants were slight,91% patients thought the curative effect were well,and 78% of them tended to accept medication therapy for long time,while the results in non-psychiatrists group were 40%,81%,and 57% respectively.And the compliance would be improved with the improvement of the therapy.Conclusion:There is great difference in therapeutic pattern coping with depression between psychiatrists and non-psychiatrists.Effective measures should be taken in order to strengthen the management of non-psychiatrists in general hospitals.