Abstract:Numerous functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) data analysis strategies have been used by different laboratories to enhance the detection of brain activation. A consensus has not been achieved regarding the relative statistical power of different strategies. In this report, we compared several commonly-used data analysis strategies for conventional (nonechoplanar imaging) fMRI data by evaluating statistical testing, spatial filtering, and thresholding. The strategies were assessed using synthetic fMRI images, which were produced by introducing focal "activations" of known intensity, size, and location into "resting" images of six normal volunteers. Three parametric statistical tests (paired t-test, independent t-test, and crosscorrelation coefficient) and three nonparametric statistical tests (Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, Wilcoxon signed rank test, and Mann-Whitney test) were evaluated in terms of sensitivity, specificity, and normality. The results indicated that the independent t-test and crosscorrelation coefficient were the most powerful statistical tests, performing identically well. The effects of smoothing on the detection of activation were assessed. Sensitivity of detecting brain activation can be enhanced by a factor of 8.7 by spatially filtering the raw image data. The optimal full width at half magnitude (FWHM) of the spatial filter was determined to be two pixels (2 mm) in this study. The conventional intensity-only thresholding (IOT) technique was compared with the combined use of the spatial-extent and intensity thresholding (SEe-IT). A highly significant increase in sensitivity (up to 30-fold) was obtained using the SEe-IT technique compared to the IOT technique. Finally, the SEe-IT method was parametrically optimized. A large extent threshold proved more sensitive for detecting brain activation.

A New Activation Detecting Method Based on Combination of Statistical Parametric Mapping with the Independent Component Analysis

Detecting Brain Activations by Constrained Non-Negative Matrix Factorization from Task-Related BOLD Fmri

Unified SPM-ICA for fMRI analysis.

A Novel Unified SPM-ICA-PCA Method for Detecting Epileptic Activities in Resting-State fMRI

Spatial Independent Component Analysis Of Multitask-Related Activation In Fmri Data

A New Post-Processing Method of Applying Independent Component Analysis to Fmri Data

Analysis and Visualization Methods for Detecting Functional Activation Using Laser Speckle Contrast Imaging

Detection of fine-scale activity patterns by integration of information, in local regions

A practical model-based segmentation approach for improved activation detection in single-subject functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging studies

Improved Application of Independent Component Analysis to Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study Via Linear Projection Techniques

Generalized fMRI activation detection via Bayesian magnitude change point model

Identifying Activated Brain Regions from Fmri Data Based on Blind Non-Negative Component Separation Technique.

Modeling Motor Task Activation from Resting-State Fmri Using Machine Learning in Individual Subjects

Discussion on the choice of separated components in fMRI data analysis by spatial independent component analysis

Quantitative Evaluation of Activation State in Functional Brain Imaging

Independent Component Analysis of Instantaneous Power-Based Fmri.

[A Method Based on Independent Component Analysis for Processing Fmri Data].

A Task-Frequency-Related Approach For Detecting Activation In Functional Mri

Spatial Independent Component Analysis for Multi-task Functional MRI Data Processing

Adaptive Thresholding of Statistical Parametric Map in Fmri

Assessment and Optimization of Functional MRI Analyses