The Analysis of Misdiagnosis and Miss-Diagnosis of Hepatocellular Carcinoma with Multiphase Spiral CT Scanning (report of 44 Cases)

严福华,曾蒙苏,周康荣,陈惠明,陈锦,陈刚

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-0313.2001.06.002

2001-01-01

Abstract:Objective:To investigate the causes of misdiagnosis and miss diagnosis of HCC with multiphase spiral CT by analyzing their CT findings.Methods:44 cases of HCC proved surgically and pathologically were performed pre and post contrast CT scanning at GE Hispeed Advantage CT scanner. The multi phase enhanced CT scanning was done as follows:the arterial phase (AP) scanning at 25～30s after the injection of contrast medium,the portal phase(PVP) scanning at 70s,and the delayed scanning at 3～4 minutes.The location and pattern of lesion enhanced were observed subsequently.Results:Each of the 8 lesions misdiagnosed was less than 1 cm in diameter . Of the 8 lesions,3 were not detected in multiphase scanning and the remaining 5 could be found if carefully observed and analyzed .9 lesions were misdiagnosed as extrahepatic lesions such as adrenal tumors,gastric leiomyoma,gall bladder cancer and accessory spleen.But all of them had typical enhanced pattern of HCC.22 lesions were misdiagnosed as other intrahepatic diseases due to atypical enhanced pattern of HCC.The atypical enhanced patterns were as follows: the lesions enhanced markedly in the AP were becoming isodense or slight hyperdense in the PVP and delayed phase(DP); peritumor rim was enhanced in ring like or punctual shape in the AP and lasted enhancement during the PVP and DP; the lesion was not enhanced in the multiphase scanning. 3 lesions with fat content were misdiagnosed as hepatic angiomyolipoma. Conclusion:The special pathological change and the growth mode of HCC can result in the atypical enhanced CT findings in the multiphase scanning, which is the main cause of misdiagnosis.Understanding it thoroughly and analyzing carefully the images can improve the diagnostic accuracy of HCC. But the limitation is in the detection of micro HCC and differential diagnosis of cirrhotic nodules from hypovascular HCC.