Abstract:Abstract Background Genomic selection uses dense single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNP) markers to predict breeding values, as compared to conventional evaluations which estimate polygenic effects based on phenotypic records and pedigree information. The objective of this study was to compare polygenic, genomic and combined polygenic-genomic models, including mixture models (labelled according to the percentage of genotyped SNP markers considered to have a substantial effect, ranging from 2.5% to 100%). The data consisted of phenotypes and SNP genotypes (10,946 SNPs) of 2,188 mice. Various growth, behavioural and physiological traits were selected for the analysis to reflect a wide range of heritabilities (0.10 to 0.74) and numbers of detected quantitative traits loci (QTL) (1 to 20) affecting those traits. The analysis included estimation of variance components and cross-validation within and between families. Results Genomic selection showed a high predictive ability (PA) in comparison to traditional polygenic selection, especially for traits of moderate heritability and when cross-validation was between families. This occurred although the proportion of genomic variance of traits using genomic models was 22 to 33% smaller than using polygenic models. Using a 2.5% mixture genomic model, the proportion of genomic variance was 79% smaller relative to the polygenic model. Although the proportion of variance explained by the markers was reduced further when a smaller number of SNPs was assumed to have a substantial effect on the trait, PA of genomic selection for most traits was little affected. These low mixture percentages resulted in improved estimates of single SNP effects. Genomic models implemented for traits with fewer QTLs showed even lower PA than the polygenic models. Conclusions Genomic selection generally performed better than traditional polygenic selection, especially in the context of between family cross-validation. Reducing the number of markers considered to affect the trait did not significantly change PA for most traits, particularly in the case of within family cross-validation, but increased the number of markers found to be associated with QTLs. The underlying number of QTLs affecting the trait has an effect on PA, with a smaller number of QTLs resulting in lower PA using the genomic model compared to the polygenic model.

Comparison of REML and MCMC for Genetic Variance Component Model of Quantitative Trait in Nuclear Family

Mixed Model Approaches for Diallel Analysis Based on a Bio-Model.

Mixed Linear Model Approaches for Analyzing Genetic Models of Complex Quantitative Traits

Efficient Monte Carlo algorithm for restricted maximum likelihood estimation of genetic parameters

A Comparison of REML and Bayesian Estimation of Variance Components for Unbalanced One-way Random Effects Models With Small Sample Sizes

Monte Carlo Simulation for Analyzing ADAA Models and Seed Models Based on the Triallel Mating Design

Newton-type Methods for REML Estimation in Genetic Analysis of Quantitative Traits

Comparison and robustness of the REML, ML, MIVQUE estimators for multi-level random mediation model

A logistic mixture model for a family-based association study

High-dimensional genome-wide association study and misspecified mixed model analysis

[Analytic Methods for Seed Models with Genotype X Environment Interactions].

A compressed variance component mixed model framework for detecting small and linked QTL-by-environment interactions

Comparison of REML methods for the study of phenome-wide genetic variation

Modeling QTL-by-environment interactions for multi-parent populations

Comparison of Software Algorithms for Calculating Reml Wald Type Confidence Limits for the Between-Group Variance Component in A Small Sample One-Way Random Effects Model Example

Bias in Estimates of Quantitative-Trait–Locus Effect in Genome Scans: Demonstration of the Phenomenon and a Method-of-Moments Procedure for Reducing Bias

The Mixed or Multilevel Model for Behavior Genetic Analysis

A compressed variance component mixed model for detecting QTNs and QTN-by-environment and QTN-by-QTN interactions in genome-wide association studies

A Monte Carlo Study of the Effects of Common Method Variance on Significance Testing and Parameter Bias in Hierarchical Linear Modeling

Comparison Of Marker Intervals And Number Of Sib Pairs Used For Linkage Analysis On Simulated Nuclear Family Data

Efficiency of genomic selection using Bayesian multi-marker models for traits selected to reflect a wide range of heritabilities and frequencies of detected quantitative traits loci in mice