Abstract:In this paper, we affirm our earlier findings of evidence for a limit to human lifespan. In particular, we assess the analyses in extreme value theory (EVT) performed by Rootz\'en and Zholud. We find that their criticisms of our work are unfounded and that their analyses are contradicted by several other papers using EVT. Furthermore, we find that even if we completely accept the conclusions about late-life human mortality reached by Rootz\'en and Zholud, their results do not actually contradict the findings presented in our original paper: whether unbounded or not, human lifespan is unlikely to greatly exceed 120 years, and the improbability of longer survival---whether it is exactly zero or merely astronomically small---acts as a de facto limit. In order to eliminate the confusion surrounding the issue, we propose the adoption of the term "limit" to denote the age at which the chance of survival is exactly zero and the term "effective limit" to denote the age at which the change of survival falls below a given threshold. Once this distinction is made, it can be demonstrated that the final result of Rootz\'en and Zholud is essentially a recapitulation of the main conclusion of our paper. Ultimately, much of the controversy surrounding the issue of a limit to human lifespan can be avoided by carefully reading the literature and applying statistics to practical human scales.

A Reflection on the Model of Perminent Life and Its Significance

Perpetual Thriving

Evolution of the Concept of “Personal”and the Spirit of the Age——From“the Abstract Person”to“Realistic Individual”and “Civil Society”

Aging:A Life Science Approach

The Reflection of Humanistic Value Between Chinese Classics and Western Classics

Research on the inheritance model of the famous experienced doctors of traditional Chinese medicine

The Cultural Comparisons and Bioethical Reflections of the View of Life and Death between China and the West——And Discussions on Developmental Tendency of Future Scientific Civilization

A Few Words on Culture

Immortality as a physical problem

Interpretation of and Reflection upon the "Discourse of Cultural Extinction"

Universal Mortality Law, Life Expectancy and Immortality

Ambivalence in Discourse of "life-world”and Consciousness of survival Theory

On the non-finality of physical death in classical Confucianism

With or Without Cultural Life?

Basic Pattern of Cultural Inheritance

A comparative study on ancient view of life and death in China and western countries and the performances in literary works

Cultural Reflection of Life Philosophy——Contrastive Study of Luxun and Dostoyevsky's Consciousness of Death

Human life is unlimited - but short

The shortness of human life constitutes its limit

Why Gilgamesh failed: the mechanistic basis of the limits to human lifespan

A Discussion on Life and Death between Chinese and Western Traditional Cultures