Treatment of terrible tyriad of the elbow:a cohort study
Jun Fan,Yi Luo,Xiaotao Long,Ge Wan,Lei Wang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3877/cma.j.issn.2095-5790.2016.02.008
2016-01-01
Abstract:Background The terrible triad of the elbow is a special type of injury which refers to the posterior dislocation of the elbow with fractures of the radial head and the coronoid process. Hotchkiss firstly named it in 1 996 and detailed by Pugh in 2002.In 2005,it was pointed out by Amstrong that the injury often involved medial and lateral collateral ligaments,extensor and flexor tendons,and some other parts.It is often caused by high-energy trauma.This injury is complex, difficult to treat and often with poor prognosis.In the past,conservative treatment such as closed reduction and plaster cast immobilization and others were often used in the treatment of the terrible triad of the elbow.Surgery has become the prior option with the development of new ideas,surgical techniques and surgical equipments.However,a contradiction between the elbow immobilization for stability and the early exercises for function recovery occurs during the treatment after operation. Long period immobilization leads to stiffness of elbow and other adverse outcomes,so early functional exercise is a key factor influencing outcome after operation.Therefore,it is particularly important that the stable structures of bone and soft tissue are rigidly fixed during the surgery.Since January 2010 to June 201 5,1 6 patients of terrible triad of the elbow were treated in our hospital with open reduction and internal fixation and ligament reconstruction.Early functional exercise was carried out with the affected extremity in removable brace.The purpose of the article is to review the cases of the terrible triad of the elbow and observe their clinical outcome after surgery and postoperative early exercise. Methods General data:inclusion criteria:(1)clear history of trauma:high energy injuries like traffic accident,falling, etc.; (2 )dislocation of elbow joint; (3 )X-ray films and CT scans revealed accompanied fractures of the radial head and the coronoid process of ulna;(4 )postoperative visits should be at least 6 months;(5 )The time from injury to surgery should be less than 3 weeks. Exclusion criteria:(1)other dislocations or injuries such as olecranal fracture,etc.;(2 )the affected limb is accompanied with neurovascular injuries or fractures in other parts;(3 )elbow dysfunction before injury;(4 )patients with conservative treatment.Fracture types:Mason classification was applied in the radial head fracture and Regan-Morry classification was applied in the ulnar coronoid process fracture.Surgical method:the patient was on supine position with a thin pad under the ipsilateral scapula.The affected limb was flexed and put on the chest.Under tourniquet control,the lateral incision of elbow was firstly made till deep fascia and the lateral intramuscular septum was separated to further expose the radial head,lateral collateral ligament and joint capsule.Attention should be paid to protect the radial nerve.Then the anteromedial incision was made to separate the flexor till the elbow joint capsule of anteromedial side and expose the medial collateral ligament and the fragments of ulnar coronoid process.The articular cavity was irrigated to clean blood blot and tiny fragments of bone and cartilage.The repair was carried out by the following orders:ulnar coronoid process → medial collateral ligament and anteromedial joint capsule → fracture of radial head →lateral collateral ligament → common extensor origin.The fractures of ulnar coronoid process and radial head were fixed with mini screw plate system,Herbert screws,cannulated screws or different sutures according to classification and fragment size. The medial and lateral collateral ligaments were reconstructed with suture anchors or sutures and then the elbow was immobilized with the hinged brace after surgery.Postoperative management:The patient was asked to move the ipsilateral fingers as the anesthesia faded.The flexion and extension exercises of fingers could train the isometric contraction of forearm muscles and increase the muscle strength,which was helpful to reduce swelling and observe whether the vessels and nerves were damaged.Three days after surgery,the patient was guided to do passive elbow extension and flexion 10-1 5 minutes each time and 3 times per day,and the range of motion was limited to the degree of patients′ tolerance.After training,the elbow was maintained at 100°of flexion with brace.Seven days after operation,the brace was removed and the elbow rehabilitation was initiated with the CPM machine:angles from small to large,times from less to more,and the numbers and groups were gradually increased to meet the satisfactory range of motion.Four weeks after operation,the brace was discarded for active training of flexion,extension and forearm rotation.Every patient took oral Celebrex 1 tablets each time and 2 times per day to reduce pain and to prevent heterotopic ossification.Follow ups:Outpatient follow ups started at the 1st,3rd,6th,and 12th month,including swelling,pain,X-ray films and elbow range of motion. Four aspects were included in Mayo elbow performance score (MEPS):pain (45 points),range of motion (20 points),joint stability (10 points)and daily motion function (25 points).The total score was greater than or equal to 90 points for excellent,75-89 points for good,60-74 points for qualified, and less than 60 points for failed.Relative complications:postoperative infection,unhealing wound, nerve injury,heterotopic ossification,etc.Statistical method:The SPSS 20.0 software was used for descriptive analysis and all data were presented as x- ±s standard deviation.Results All cases were followed up for 6 to 12 (9.1 9±2.56)months.In the last follow-up,the fractures of 1 6 cases were all well healed,1 case had postoperative infection,no complications such as vascular and nerve injury occurred,and 1 case had heterotopic ossification.Elbow range of motion in all patients:range of extension was -20°-10°(-2.1 9±10.1 6)°,range of flexion was 65°-135°(102.1 9±1 6.02)°,range of pronation was 25°-60°(47.1 9 ± 10.48)°,and range of supination was 35°-70°(50.63 ± 1 1.53 )°.The MEPS score ranged from 5 1-95(84.9 ±10.4)points with 6 excellent cases,8 good cases and 2 poor cases.Conclusions The terrible triad of elbow is a complex injury of bone and soft tissue structure caused by high-energy trauma.Poor function is often seen because of elbow adhesions and stiffness. The early correct surgical treatment and rehabilitation play a crucial role in the recovery of elbow function.We adopt the internal and external fixation techniques,restore the bony anatomical structure and the integrity of joint capsule and collateral ligaments,enhance the internal fixation stability with external brace,strengthen the stability of elbow joint and thus provide conditions for early functional exercises.Early functional training promotes blood circulation,improves bone microcirculation,and then largely shortens the healing time of injury.