PERFORMANCES OF SURPLUS PRODUCTION MODELS IN DIFFERENT FISHING SCENARIOS

倪建峰,刘群

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-6482.2004.01.010

2004-01-01

Abstract:Surplus production models, because of their simplicit and relatively undemanding of data, are attractive tools for many fish stock assessments. The paper compares the most popularly used surplus production models using simulated data and swordfish (xiphias gladius) fishery data in the North Atlantic Ocean. None of the four models could work well in scenario 2, an under-exploited stock.. However, the produced accurate results in scenario 1. The Schnute model worked well for fully-exploited stocks such as those in scenarios 3,4 and 5, especially for low biomass stocks such as scenario 3, but not suitable to under-exploited stocks such as scenario 2. The Walters-Hilborn model (W-H model) generally did well in all kinds of scenarios especially in scenrios 1,4, and 5. We have obtained accurate estimates of q for high fishing effort fisheries (scenarios 3,4). For swordfish (xiphias gladius) fishery, the estimation from the models produced and MSY of about 14500 tons, very near the result of Prager in 1996.