Abstract:Discussions about unilateral trade measures as a means to combat climate change have become quite fashionable notwithstanding warnings against unilateralism and protectionism from the leaders of G-8 and G-20 in times of an economic crisis. A system of ‘border tax adjustment’ on imports is suggested in order to countervail the cost of domestic emission trading systems. The proponents argue that without such measures, a country having adopted an emission trading system would not only lose economically but also environmentally. The standard reason given to justify this argument is the notion of carbon leakage, namely, the danger that energy-intensive production would move from countries with domestic policies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions based on a carbon price for emitters to regions that do not have a binding and costly regulatory CO2 regime. Recently, the discussions have been fuelled by the Waxman/Markey Bill, adopted on 26 June 2009 by the House of Representatives and by a French non-paper, presented at the informal EU Environment Council held in July 2009. These two initiatives aim to establish, in the context of a domestic emission trading system, a system of ‘border tax adjustment’ against some imports from some countries, namely, those that are seen as not contributing enough in the fight against climate change. The revised European ETS Directive does not provide for border measures. It instructs the European Commission to submit a report to the Council and the European Parliament no later than 30 June 2010 assessing whether energy-intensive sectors are exposed to a significant risk of carbon leakage and explicitly outlines the inclusion of imports in the European Union’s ETS system as one of several actions. The joint WTO-UNEP paper on trade and climate change has been widely regarded as a justification from a legal point of view of such measures. While there are many proponents for such measures, there remains a considerable amount of skepticism; politicians, business organizations, and scholars have warned against such an approach. The following short note will discuss the feasibility of ‘border tax adjustment’ in relation to domestic climate change legislation as well as some WTO legal aspects along the following questions: (1) Are there target countries for border measures? (2) Would border measures help to combat climate change and could they be administered without too much bureaucracy? (3) How should border measures be qualified under General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT)?

On the Illegality of EU's Unilateral Measure to Tax Airlines for Their Greenhouse Gas Emissions from the Perspective of International Law

An International Law Analysis of EU Carbon Emissions Reduction Rules in the Aviation Industry

A Study on EU's Inclusion of Civil Aviation into EU Emission Trading System

Carbon Emission Trading Scheme in the shipping sector: Drivers, challenges, and impacts

Research Advances on Economic Impacts of EU Aviation Carbon Trading

Towards carbon neutrality in shipping: Impact of European Union's emissions trading system for shipping and China's response

The EU emissions trading system and airline low-carbon transition: A game-theoretic approach

Market-Based Measures: The European Union Emission Trading Scheme and the Carbon Offsetting and Reduction Scheme for International Aviation

Market Competition and Greening Transportation of Airlines under the Emission Trading Scheme: A Case of Duopoly Market

Divergences Between the European Union and China on Reducing International Aviation Emissions

On Methodological Significance of Law and Policy of EU on Greenhouse Gases Emission Reduction

Research on the Impacts of European Union Aviation Carbon Trading on China's Aviation Passenger Transport

The EU Emission Trading System Tax Regime and the Issue of Unfair Maritime Competition

Measuring The Energy Efficiency For Airlines Under The Pressure Of Being Included Into The Eu Ets

The Effect Of Carbon Tax In Aviation Industry On The Multilateral Simulation Game

Breathing Life into the Carbon Market: Legal Frameworks of Emissions Trading in Europe

Exploring the Impacts of EU ETS on the Pollution Abatement Costs of European Airlines: an Application of Network Environmental Production Function

Border Tax Adjustment to Combat Carbon Leakage: A Myth

Accounting for Carbon Pricing in Third Countries Under the EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism

Estudos de cenários de implantação de um imposto ambiental no transporte aéreo no Brasil

Some Analyses on the EU Emissions Trading Scheme and Its Effects