Abstract:River restoration programmes with the goal of conserving and rehabilitating inland fishes have a multi‐decadal history, but evaluation and synthesis of past restoration actions have been limited by a lack of monitoring and reporting. Given that calls for both monitoring and systematic reviews of restoration have increased, we were interested in the influence that restoration has had on improving conditions for riverine fishes resulting from long‐standing and increasingly prominent stressors. Our objectives were to (1) identify which stressors were targeted in river restoration efforts, (2) determine the proportion of published studies that articulate restoration goals and develop comparative monitoring designs for assessing the effects of restoration on fishes, and (3) conduct a meta‐analysis to synthesise fish responses to restoration projects. We assessed restoration effectiveness for increasing fish density and richness from peer‐reviewed papers published over the past decade using a global systematic review and meta‐analysis. We found that restoration actions addressed major stressors primarily by improving in‐stream habitat (37%), increasing in‐stream longitudinal connectivity (26%) and increasing lateral floodplain connections (9%). Although 81% of studies had comparative monitoring designs (i.e., before/after and control/impact) and stated restoration goals, only 40% of those studies reported sufficient data to be included in the meta‐analysis. Projects which increased in‐stream connectivity had the largest positive effect size on fish density and richness compared to in‐stream habitat improvements and increasing floodplain connections. Time since restoration and restoration size (i.e., geographical footprint) were not strong predictors of fish response effect sizes. Restoration effectiveness was highly variable among project types. Authors of studies included in the meta‐analysis often identified spatial or temporal scale of monitoring, overriding catchment conditions, and recolonisation potential as sources of variability and effectiveness in restoration outcomes. Systematic reporting of these and other covariates may help guide processes in restoration evaluation and provide valuable research insights. Despite increased emphasis on monitoring, incomplete data reporting limited the number of studies that could be included for quantitative meta‐analysis. Persistent emphasis on setting specific criteria (e.g., measurable outcomes of fish response) for restoration goals, project monitoring, data reporting, information sharing and collaborative projects is likely to continue to improve understanding of restoration effectiveness transferable to future endeavours. Our results can be used to support river restoration practitioners with evidence‐based information to evaluate the cost–benefit ratio of competing restoration priorities, and inform restoration planning and implementation for riverine fish.

Effect assessment of marine fishery stock enhancement: A review of the literature

Impacts of Fishing on the Marine Mean Trophic Level in Chinese Marine Area

Evaluating Ecosystem Characteristics and Ecological Carrying Capacity for Marine Fauna Stock Enhancement Within a Marine Ranching System

Effective fisheries management instrumental in improving fish stock status

Characterizing the development of Sea ranching in China

Effects of stock enhancement on the macrobenthic community and ecological health in the intertidal zone of the estuarine wetland in Nanhui, China

Spatiotemporal dynamics and resource use efficiency in mariculture production: A case study in Southeastern China

Estimating ecological carrying capacity for stock enhancement in marine ranching ecosystems of Northern China

Effects of Two Environmental Enrichment Methods on Cognitive Ability and Growth Performance of Juvenile Black Rockfish Sebastes schlegelii

Evaluation of the Effectiveness of Marine Protected Areas: Methodologies and Progress

Measuring fisheries outcomes from coastal wetland restoration: a review and meta‐analysis

The enhancement effect of fishery resources on artificial reefs in marine ranching area in Zhangzi Island

How ecological processes shape the outcomes of stock enhancement and harvest regulations in recreational fisheries.

Fishery Stock Assessments in the Min River Estuary and Its Adjacent Waters in Southern China Using the Length-Based Bayesian Estimation (LBB) Method

Mechanism of action of marine ecological restoration on ecological, economic, and social benefits—An empirical analysis based on a structural equation model

Improvement on the Effectiveness of Marine Stock Enhancement in the Artificial Reef Area by a New Cage-Based Release Technique

Economic, ecological and genetic impacts of marine stock enhancement and sea ranching: A systematic review

Evaluating effectiveness of restoration to address current stressors to riverine fish

Direct and Indirect Effects of a Fishing Ban on Lacustrine Fish Community Do Not Result in a Full Recovery

An improved method of assessing marine utilization impact to describe the man-land relationship for coastal management: a case study of the Laizhou Bay, China

Assessing the Management Effectiveness of China's Marine Protected Areas: Challenges and Recommendations