Abstract:Background Port wine birthmark (PWB) is a congenital vascular malformation of the skin. Pulsed dye laser (PDL) is the "gold standard" for the treatment of PWB globally. Hematoporphyrin monomethyl ether (HMME or hemoporfin)‐mediated photodynamic therapy (HMME–PDT) has emerged as the first choice for PWB treatment, particularly for young children, in many major hospitals in China during the past several decades. Aim To evaluate whether HMME–PDT is superior to PDL by comparing the clinical efficacies of both modalities. Method PubMed records were searched for all relevant studies of PWB treatment using PDL (1988−2023) or HMME–PDT (2007−2023). Patient characteristics and clinical efficacies were extracted. Studies with a quartile percentage clearance or similar scale were included. A mean color clearance index (CI) per study was calculated and compared among groups. An overall CI (C0), with data weighted by cohort size, was used to evaluate the final efficacy for each modality. Result A total of 18 HMME–PDT studies with 3910 patients in China were eligible for inclusion in this analysis. Similarly, 40 PDL studies with 5094 patients from nine different countries were eligible for inclusion in this analysis. Over 58% of patients in the HMME‐PDT studies were minors (<18 years old). A significant portion (21.3%) were young children (<3 years old). Similarly, 33.2% of patients in the PDL studies were minors. A small proportion (9.3%) was young children. The overall clearance rates for PDL were slightly, but not significantly, higher than those for HMME–PDT in cohorts with patients of all ages (C0, 0.54 vs. 0.48, p = 0.733), subpopulations with only minors (C0, 0.54 vs. 0.46, p = 0.714), and young children (C0, 0.67 vs. 0.50, p = 0.081). Regrettably, there was a lack of long‐term data on follow‐up evaluations for efficacy and impact of HMME‐PDT on young children in general, and central nervous system development in particular, because their blood‐brain barriers have a greater permeability as compared to adults. Conclusion PDL shows overall albeit insignificantly higher clearance rates than HMME‐PDT in patients of all ages; particularly statistical significance is nearly achieved in young children. Collectively, current evidence is insufficient to support HMME–PDT as the first choice of treatment of PWBs in young children given: (1) overall inferior efficacy as compared to PDL; (2) risk of off‐target exposure to meningeal vasculature during the procedure; (3) administration of steriods for mitigation of side effects; ‐and (4) lack of long‐term data on the potential impact of HMME on central nervous system development in young children.

Early Clinical Treatment of Infant Port-Wine Stains with Multiple Kinds of Laser

Treatment of Port-Wine Stains with the 595-Nm Pulsed Dye Laser: A Pilot Study in Chinese Patients

Flashlamp-pumped pulsed dye laser (595 nm) for the treatment of port-wine stains: a clinical review of 1560 patients

Weekly Pulsed Dye Laser Treatments for Port-Wine Birthmarks in Infants

Clinical Efficacy of OPT Intense Pulsed Light Combined Parameters in Treatment of Lip Hairiness

Efficacy of Pulsed Dual-Wavelength 595 and 1064 Nm Laser in Treatment of Superficial Infantile Hemangioma

Anatomical observations of holoprosencephaly in swine.

Therapeutic Effect of Intense Pulsed Light with Optimal Pulse Technology on Meibomian Gland Dysfunction with and Without Ocular Demodex Infestation

Evaluation of a New Q-switched Nd:YAG Laser on Premacular Hemorrhage.

Non-invasive efficacy assessment of pulsed dye laser and photodynamic therapy for port-wine stain

Efficacy and influential factors of hematoporphyrin monomethyl ether mediated photodynamic therapy in the treatment for port-wine stains

Clinical efficacy of the 595 nm pulsed dye laser in the treatment of childhood superficial hemangioma – analysis of 10-year application in Chinese patients

Efficacy of photodynamic therapy in the treatment of port wine stains: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The calculation of excitation energies based on the relativistic two-component zeroth-order regular approximation and time-dependent density-functional with full use of symmetry.

Therapy‐related preleukemic syndrome

Efficacy and safety of hemoporfin photodynamic therapy for port-wine stains in paediatric patients: A retrospective study of 439 cases at a single centre

Comparing HMME-PDT and Cynergy Dual-Wavelength Laser in the Treatment of Facial PWS.

Photocoagulation of dermal blood vessels with multiple laser pulses in an in vivo microvascular model

Current clinical evidence is insufficient to support HMME–PDT as the first choice of treatment for young children with port wine birthmarks

Efficacy and Safety of Hemoporfin in Photodynamic Therapy for Port-Wine Stain: A Multicenter and Open-Labeled Phase Iia Study