Abstract:Background The National Health and Family Planning Commission of China has issued more than 400 clinical pathways to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of medical care delivered by public hospitals in China. The aim of our study is to determine whether patient care is compliant with national clinical pathways in public general hospitals of Pudong New Area in Shanghai. Methods We identified the clinical pathways established by the National Health and Family Planning Commission of China for 5 common conditions (community-acquired pneumonia, acute myocardial infarction (AMI), heart failure, cesarean section, type-2 diabetes). We randomly selected patients with each condition admitted to one of 7 public general hospitals in Pudong New Area in China in January, 2013. We identified key process indicators (KPIs) for each pathway and, based on chart review for each patient, determined whether the patient’s care was compliant for each indicator. We calculated the proportion of care which was compliant with clinical pathways for each indicator, the average proportion of indicators that were met for each patient, and the proportion of patients whose care was compliant for all measures. For selected indicators, we compared compliance rates among hospitals in our study with those from other countries. Results Average compliance rates across the KPIs for each condition ranged from 61 % for AMI to 89 % for pneumonia. The percent of patient receiving fully compliant care ranged from 0 for AMI and heart failure to 39 % for pneumonia. Compared to the compliance rate for process indicators in the hospitals of other countries, some rates in the hospitals that we audited were higher, but some were lower. Conclusions Few patients received care that complied with all the pathways for each condition. The reasons for low compliance with national clinical pathways and how to improve clinical quality in public hospitals of China need to be further explored.

Analysis and Countermeasures Suggestions of Influencing Factors of Clinical Pathway Completion

Improving Clinical Pathway Management by Using PDCA

Comprehensive application of four quality management tools in nursing quality management

The status of the clinical pathways’ Quality Control to domestic hospital management

Difficulties and the Point of Penetration in Clinical Pathway's Implementation

A Method to Evaluate Critical Factors for Successful Implementation of Clinical Pathways

Analysis on Clinical Pathway Management at Public Hospitals in China

PDCA Circulation Facilitating Clinical Pathway’s Implementation

Analysis on Factors Influencing the Number of Clinical Pathways Implemented at Public Hospitals

The Analysis of Awareness of the Clinical Pathway among Medical Staff in a Pilot Hospital

Analysis of the Implementation of Clinical Pathways Among Physicians in Public Hospitals

Factors Associated with the Implementation of Clinical Pathways and the Evaluation of its Effects Among Physicians

Analysis on the Implementation of Clinical Pathways at Public Hospitals in China

Evaluation of the Implementation and Effects of Clinical Pathways by Physicians in Public Hospitals

Clinical Pathway Management:Review and Prospect

Management Quality Improvement of Hospital Scientific and Technological Achievements Transformation Based on PDCA Cycle

Clinical Pathway Management and Information Systems Combination Strategy

The Role of Clinical Pharmacists in the Clinical Pathway

Improvement of Electronic Medical Records Based on Clinical Pathway

Variation and Influencing Factors in Clinical Pathway of Ischemic Stroke:A Retrospective Study

Compliance with Clinical Pathways for Inpatient Care in Chinese Public Hospitals