Abstract:Enhancing the temporal competitiveness of public transit (PT) over private cars is a crucial strategy for promoting PT mode share and alleviating traffic congestion, especially for commuter trips. However, to our best knowledge, previous studies have rarely considered the impact of time reliability and analyzed the critical stages (e.g., accessing, waiting, transferring) that affect PT competitiveness. To fill these research gaps, we develop a comprehensive set of indicators to evaluate the effect of temporal reliability on the competitiveness of PT compared to private cars for commuter trips. We then conduct a detailed examination of the commuting competitiveness of PT at both the Origin-Destination (OD) and Traffic Analysis Zone (TAZ) levels by combining data from various sources obtained from Hangzhou, China. The results show that the average competitiveness of PT increases after considering reliability. Metro competitiveness rises significantly, and bus competitiveness increases for short trips but decreases for long trips. Furthermore, the bus is far less competitive than the metro, and TAZs near the metro stations could be highly competitive. Moreover, in-bus time affects bus competitiveness primarily, and improving the accessibility of metro stations is essential to enhance metro competitiveness. In conclusion, the proposed methodology presents a comprehensive approach to assess the competitiveness of PT versus cars, including travel time reliability. This methodology enables a more nuanced understanding of the factors influencing PT competitiveness and offers valuable insights for strategically intervening to enhance its performance effectively.

Evaluation of Time Benefits by Improving Level of Traffic Management

Study on Evaluation of National Economic Benefit of Urban Traffic Management

Surrogate‐Based Optimization of Expensive‐to‐Evaluate Objective for Optimal Highway Toll Charges in Transportation Network

EVALUATION ON THE MICROECONOMIC BENEFITS OF ZHEJIANG EXPRESSWAY

Evaluation of urban traffic management in China

Optimizing the numbe r fo buses stopping at on-line stops under mxi ed traffic conditions

An Analysis on Effectiveness of Transportation Demand Management in Beijing

Study on Signal Timing Methods of Optimizing Urban Transportation Network Efficiency

Comparison and optimization of cordon and area pricings for managing travel demand

Competitiveness of Public Transit Considering Travel Time Reliability: A Case Study for Commuter Trips in Hangzhou, China

Research And Application On Urban Traffic Level Of Service Evaluation Method Based On Attribute Mathematics

Comprehensive Evaluation Index System and Method of the Development Level of Urban Traffic

Second-best congestion pricing models for multiple time periods and multiple travelers

Evaluation of Traffic Congestion Degree: an Integrated Approach.

Study on Signal Timing Method Based on People

Study on the Method of Traffic State Change Time on Urban Expressway

An Optimization Method of Time Window Based on Travel Time and Reliability

Evaluating Traveler Information Effects on Commercial and Noncommercial Users

Critical Traffic Volume of Traffic Signal Warrant at Major-Minor Intersections

Benefit Evaluation Framework of Intelligent Transportation Systems

Benefits and Evaluation of ITS Projects - Examples from China