Comparison of laparoscopic adrenalectomy and open adrenalectomy for large benign adrenal tumors

赵琪,刘宇军,孙立安,张立,许明,朱同玉,郭剑明
2013-01-01
Journal of Clinical Urology
Abstract:Objective:To compare laparoscopic adrenalectomy(LA)with open adrenalectomy(OA)for benign adrenal masses larger than 6cm.Method:The data of 50patients with large adrenal benign masses(6cm)from Jan.2009to Dec.2011were reviewed.Twenty-six patients underwent LA and 24for OA.The tumor size,the age of patients and operative time,volume of blood loss during operation,hospital stay,length of incision and the hemodynamic variation of pheochromocytoma underwent two types of operations were analyzed.Result:Histopathological examination confirmed adrenal adenoma in two,ganglioneuroma in ten,pheochromocytoma in 13, myelolipoma in 19,adrenal cyst combined with hemorrhage in three,schwannoglioma in two,Castleman disease in one.The mean age,size of the tumor were(45.3±15.6)years and(52.2±13.2)years(P=0.069),(7.75± 1.26)cm and(8.38±1.96)cm(P=0.098)in LA and OA group respectively.The mean operative time,blood loss,hospital stay,and length of incision were(65.2±23.4)min and(126.9±32.5)min(P0.01),(54.1± 19.5)ml and(205.0±49.6)ml(P0.01),(4.8±1.6)d and(7.6±2.1)d(P0.01),(7.56±2.06)cm and(18.28±3.25)cm(P0.01)in two groups respectively.There was no intraoperative complication and conversions to an open procedure in LA group.An unilateral nephrectomy was needed in one case with Castleman disease because of intraoperative injury of renal hilum in OA group.There was no recurrence in either group during follow-up period of three to 26months.The average peak intraoperative blood pressure and heart rate were lower in LA group than those in OA group(P0.05).Conclusion:Compared with open adrenalectomy,laparoscopic adrenalectomy is a safe and effective treatment for large benign adrenal masses because of its successful outcome in terms of operative time,blood loss,hospital stay despite of extended incision.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?