The Application of 201tl Chloride Scintigraphy for Malignant or Benign Bone and Soft Tissue Lesions

方向前,范顺武,楼岑,余林良

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3760/j.issn:0253-2352.2003.01.010

2003-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate the clinical value of 201 Tl chloride scintigraphy in the differen-tial diagnosis of various musculoskeletal tumors.Methods 201 Tl chloride scintigraphy was performed to di ag-nose the malignancy of bone and soft tis sue tumors by visual and semi-quantitative assessment in58patients with43malignant lesions and15benign lesions.Planar images were obtained in the early phase5min after injection and the delayed phase120min.Six patients with osteosarco mas were evaluated by 201 Tl scintigra phy both pre-and post-chemotherapy,and tumor necrosis rate(TNR)were graded on the basis of percent age of tumor necrosis as defined histologically.And histological TNR was compared with the changes in the 201 Tl scintigraphic study.In all43of malignant and benign bony lesions 99m Tc-methylene-diphosphonate( 99m Tc-MDP )bone scan examination were accepted simultaneously.Results In comparison with benign tumors,malignant tumors showed longer retention and more increased uptake of the 201 Tl in the le sions on delayed images.Semi-quantitative assessment of the images changes was performed for the58cases.The early uptake ratio(UR)of 43malignant and15benign lesions was2.856±1.121and1.304±0.324re spectively,and the early UR of malignant lesions was significantly higher than that of benign le sions(t=5.259,P0.001).The delayed UR of 43malignant and15benign lesions was2.261±0.769and1.100±0.139re spectively,the re-sults of malig nant and benign tumors demonstrated a significant difference statistically(t=5.786,P0.001).If the tu mor with an early UR more than1.735(2.856-1.121)and delayed UR1.492(2.261-0.769)was pre sumed to be malig nancy,the percentage of sensitivities,specificities,and accuracies of 201 Tl scintigraphy in differentiating malignant lesions from benign lesions was95.35%,93.33%,and94.83%respectively.In6cases of osteosarcomas with preoperative chemotherapy,201 Tl scintigraphic changes showed the concordance with TNR,planar images of 201 Tl of 5re sponders with TNR90%showed decreased uptake ratio in the tumor le sions.Conclusion 201 Tl scintigra-phy is very useful for evalu ating the location and ex tent of tumor and differentiating malignant from benign bone and soft tissue tumors.The combination of early and delayed image is important for semi-quantitative assessment.We prefer the tumor with an early UR1.735and delayed UR1.492to be considered as malignancy.Serial 201 Tl scintigraphy,with quantitative analysis of alterations in 201 Tl uptake,may provide a potential quantitative and objective measure of the effect of preoperative chemothera py in osteosarcoma.[