Abstract:Aim This study aimed to evaluate the combination of virtual simulation and in-person simulation among undergraduate nursing students. Background At present, in-person simulation is the main form of simulation in China. With the development of computer technology, computer-based virtual simulation is gradually applied in simulation and has shown unique advantages. However, simulation format that combines virtual simulation with in-person simulation is rare in China. Design This was a mixed methods study, which applied a QUAN→qual sequential explanatory approach. Methods In the quantitative phase, a non-randomized controlled trial (NRCT) was employed among 93 junior undergraduate nursing students from nursing school of a university in China. Students from parallel classes 1, 2 and 3 (45 students) were selected as experimental group, while students from parallel classes 4, 5 and 6 (48 students) were selected as control group. The control group completed the in-person simulation, while the experimental group was required to complete both virtual simulation and in-person simulation. The students' performance in in-person simulation was evaluated by the teachers according to a demonstrating checklist. After simulation, Students were invited to answer the Students' Satisfaction and Self-confidence in Learning Scale (SSS), Educational Practices in Simulation Scale (EPSS) and Clinical Learning Environment Comparison Survey (CLECS). A descriptive qualitative study was conducted in qualitative phase. Ten students were recruited by a purposive sampling method from the experimental group and were interviewed by the researcher. A semi-structured interview method was used to conduct in-depth interviews with them. Results The mean score of the students' performance in the experimental group was higher than that in the control group (63.00 vs 57.67). There were no significant differences in learning satisfaction, self-confidence and simulated practice score (except cooperation dimension) between the two groups (P>0.05). For experimental group, the total CLECS score in in-person simulation was higher than that in virtual simulation, which was 84.98±12.50 and 72.58±13.04 respectively and the difference was statistically significant (t=5.270, p<0.001). Ten students were interviewed in the qualitative phase. Through the interview, we have learned that students believed that virtual simulation combined with in-person simulation is helpful to enhance their knowledge, improve their learning confidence and help them develop non-technical skills (i.e., decision-making and critical thinking). Conclusion In-person simulation is the preferred form of simulation and virtual simulation is a beneficial supplement to in-person simulation. The combination of the two is suggested to be introduced into the simulation curriculum for undergraduate nursing students.

Application of comprehensive simulation method in the experimental teaching of midwifery nursing

A Study on Application of Integrated Teaching Method in Nursing Undergraduate Students of Midwifery in Clinical Practice

Application of virtual simulation technology in basic nursing teaching

The Application of Scenario Simulation Teaching Combined with Case Teaching in Medical Education: Taking Nursing Practice Teaching as An Example

Construction and practice of a comprehensive nursing skills course with simulation in an RN-BSN program in China: a quasi-experimental study

The application effect of"comprehensive design experiment evaluation"in the evaluation of nursing experimental teaching

Application of Progressive Case Teaching Combined with Scenario Simulation in Comprehensive Practical Teaching of Nursing in Higher Vocational Colleges

The application of SimMom simulator in obstetrics and gynecology clinical probation teaching

Evaluation of the Applicating Results of Home-Visiting Scenario Simulation Teaching in Community Nursing Practical Teaching

Application of Task-driven Teaching Method in Midwifery for Higher Vocational Nursing Students

Application of simulation teaching method in prenatal ultrasound skills training for residents

Evaluation of the Combination of Virtual Simulation and in-person simulation among Undergraduate Nursing Students: A Mixed Methods Study

The Application of SimMom Human Analogue in Obstetrics Clinical Practice Teaching

Application of case teaching method in teaching of clinical practice for nursing undergraduate students

Application Effect of SPOC Combined Seminar Teaching in Advanced Nursing Practice Course for Postgraduates of Master of Nursing Specialist

The practice and effect evaluation of the situation simulation teaching of emergency nursing skills

Reform of the teaching methods in experimental skills of Basic Nursing Science for nursing undergraduates

Evaluating the Quality of Simulation Teaching in Fundamental Nursing Curriculum: AHP-Fuzzy Comprehensive Evaluation.

The effect of “PCMC+Scenario simulation” PAD class mode on midwifery students

Study on the application value of scenario simulation teaching combined with flipped classroom in teaching nursing interns in department of gastroenterology

Scenario simulation teaching with advanced simulated puerperas in obstetrics instruction