Optimization Strategy of Supply Chains During the Speculative Crisis of Confidence

Jian-bin LI,Xiao-meng LUO,Ming-hui XU

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1004-6062.2014.02.018

2014-01-01

Abstract:Stock-out problems often occurs after the rapid growth of consumer purchasing power,especially in the market of popular commodities. These problems become opportunities for speculators in the resale market. In general,speculators are profitable especially when production capacity cannot keep up with the actual demand. However,the resale market involves demand uncertainty risks in the beginning of the sales period.The public generally denounces speculators for extracting profits from consumers and harming the interests of manufacturers. Some speculating behaviors( e. g. ticket scalping) are even forbidden according to Chinese laws. Despite of these regulations,some existing researches show that the presence of speculators may increase a firm's expected profit as long as the firm is charging a fixed retail price because speculators often act as an intermediary for the firm to adopt dynamic pricing strategy. As a result,speculators unintentionally do some favors for some firms and it is also profitable for these firms to allow speculators to enter the market under certain conditions. In reality,not all of customers are willing to buy from speculators as more and more mercenary peddlers are selling fake and low-quality products in China. Moreover,some prudent consumers may have strong psychological distrust towards speculators because of their bad reputation,and no official guarantees for products carried by speculators,Therefore,confidence crisis reduces speculators' potential customer group size,thereby reducing profit margin and influencing speculators' behaviors. When stock-out problems happen,both consumers and firms suffer loss. Even though their valuation towards the product may turn out to be the same,different consumers may have different utility loss,which significantly affects strategic consumers' decision of buying now or later when they face stock-out problems. This is because the consumption value measured by the monetary value cannot reflect the real utility perception of a consumer to some degree. For example,two football fans have same valuation of a football match ticket,and one fan is much richer than the other one. When both of them face stock-out problem,the poorer one will be much more depressed than the rich one since the same monetary value shows different perceived values for the same football ticket as the two persons are not in the same income level.In order to describe consumer characteristics from different perspectives,including the differences in customers' attitudes towards speculators and their utility loss of stock-out,we introduce the concept of Speculative Crisis of Confidence and Consumer's Utility Loss of Stock-out in our model to simulate heterogeneous consumers in two ways. In general,we divide consumers into different types from four perspectives: strategic and myopic consumers,high valuation and low valuation consumers,consumers who will never buy products from speculators and who think it is indifferent to buy products from the firm and speculators,as well as consumers with different Consumer's Utility Loss of Stock-out.This paper considers a two-stage supply chain with a monopolist firm that sells a fixed capacity facing uncertain demand consisting of a certain part and a random part. The same market has no substitute products and large numbers of potential speculators. The firm sets a price at the beginning of the first stage before demand uncertainty is resolved to control the number of speculators that enter the market in order to maximize its own profit. The speculators enter the market at the first stage after seeing the retail price purely with the intention of reselling at the second stage,which can be profitable if the demand turns out to be high at the second stage. Afterwards,different types of consumers strategically choose when and where to purchase to maximize their own expected utility.In the first part,with the introduction of Speculative Crisis of Confidence we present a basic model with a fixed retail price,which can also mimic dynamic pricing outcomes for the firm by facilitating resale. In the second part,we do equilibrium analysis of the basic model using backward induction. In the third part,we define the concept of Consumer's Utility Loss of Stock-out by extending the basic model to a dynamic pricing model and obtaining the equilibrium solutions. By solving the equilibrium conditions of the two abovementioned models,the supplier's optimal pricing strategy and the equilibrium number of speculators of the two models are characterized to show the optimization strategy of the supply chain under different conditions. These results show the incentives of supply chain members could affect their options and reflect the interactions between their decisions.At last,in order to verify the application of the two models we conduct a numerical analysis using Matlab,which gives a real example of how different members of a supply chain make their choices under different conditions. The findings also indicate that( 1)speculators can receive a higher price with the reduction of the degree of Speculative Crisis of Confidence,and( 2) consumers with greater Consumer's Utility Loss of Stock-out Coefficient tend to make purchasing decisions in advance.