Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To investigate the effectiveness and biomechanical analysis of 3 fixation methods of screw anterior-posterior fixation (SAPF), screw posterior-anterior fixation (SPAF), and buttress plate fixation (BPF) in treatment of posterior Pilon fractures. METHODS:Fifteen fresh-frozen skeleto-ligamentous lower leg specimens were harvested to establish the models of posterior Pilon fracture, and then fracture was fixed with BPF (n = 5), SAPF (n = 5), and SPAF (n = 5). Vertical force was loaded to internal fixation failure in a speed of 1 cm/minute with servohydraulic testing machine. The instantaneous loads of 1 mm and 2 mm steps and the failure modes were recorded. Between May 2008 and December 2011, 56 patients with posterior Pilon fracture were treated with SAPF (SAPF group) in 11 cases, or SPAF (SPAF group) in 26 cases, or BPF (BPF group) in 19 cases. There was no significant difference in age, gender, injury cause, side, disease duration, and complications among groups (P > 0.05). Clinical and radiographic examinations were used to assess the reduction and healing of fracture; the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score and the visual analogue scale (VAS) were used to evaluate the functional outcomes. RESULTS:No breaking or bending was observed in all specimens, fixation failure was caused by cancellous bone compression. The instantaneous loads of 1 mm and 2 mm steps were the largest in BPF group, larger in SPAF group, and smallest in SAPF group, showing significant differences among 3 groups (P < 0.05). A total of 47 cases were followed up 16-54 months (9 in SAPF group, 22 in SPAF group, and 16 in BPF group), with a mean time of 35.2 months. Fixation failure was found in 2 cases of SAPF group; the other cases obtain bony union within 3 to 4 months (mean, 3.2 months) with no fixation failure. The AOFAS score was significantly lower in SAPF group than in SPAF and BPF groups (P < 0.05), but no significant difference was found between SPAF and BPF groups (P > 0.05). The VAS score was significantly higher in SAPF group than in SPAF and BPF groups (P < 0.05), but no significant difference was found between SPAF and BPF groups (P > 0.05). CONCLUSION:SAPF could not reach enough fixation strength for the posterior Pilon fracture; both SPAF and BPF could reach rigid fixation, and have good effectiveness. And from the biomechanical points, BPF could reach better fixation strength than screw fixations.

Treatment of Pilon Fracture of the Tibia with AO Technique

Surgical Treatment Strategy for Tibial Pilon Fracture

The Summary of Characteristic and Treatment of Pilon Fracture with Intact Fibula

Treatment for AO -C3 Pilon Fractures

Treatment of Pilon Fracture with External Fixation under Arthroscopy

Injury Mechanism, Fracture Characteristics and Clinical Treatment of Pilon Fracture with Intact Fibula-a Retrospective Study of 23 Pilon Fractures.

Internal fixation with double plates for complicated Pilon fracture

Surgical Treatment of High Energy Tibia Pilon Fracture

Classification and Treatment Progress of Pilon Fracture

Open reduction and internal fixation of posterior pilon fractures with buttress plate.

Treatment outcomes of buttress plating in treatment of posterior pilon fractures

Treatment of Pilon Fracture Malunion with Distal Tibiai Osteotomy and Reconstruction

Operative Treatment of Tibial Pilon Fractures and Clinical Analysis of 45 Eases

Research progress of delayed open reduction and locking plate in treatment of type AO-C Pilon fractures

[Effectiveness and Biomechanical Analysis of Three Fixation Methods in Treatment of Posterior Pilon Fractures].

One-stage Management of Open Distal Tibial Pilon Fractures

Study on Treatment of Pilon Fracture with Emergent Open Reduction and Limited Internal Fixation Combined with External Fixator

Use of an articulated external fixator for high energy Pilon fractures

[Clinical analysis of Pilon fractures treated through a single lateral approach for 28 patients]

[Over-articular external fixator combined with limited internal fixation for the treatment of high-energy Pilon fractures]

Early posterior column internal fixation: A staged treatment of type C3 tibial pilon fracture