Title : Deactivation of a Cobalt Catalyst for Water Reduction via
H. Baydoun,S. Mazumder,Cláudio N. Verani,Valence Tautomerism,H. Schlegel
Abstract:The activity of the water reduction catalyst [Co(L)(pyr)2]PF6 (1), where (L ) is a bis-amido pyridine ligand and pyr is pyrrolidine, is investigated. Catalyst 1 has an overpotential of 0.54 V and a high observed TOF of 23 min, albeit for a relatively short time. Considering the significant activity of 1 and aiming to improve catalyst design, a detailed structural and electronic study is performed to understand the mechanisms of deactivation. Experimental and theoretical evidence support that the metal-reduced [Co(L)] is in tautomeric equilibrium with the ligand-reduced [Co(L)] species. While [Co(L)] favors formation of a Co–H relevant for catalysis, the [Co(L)] species leads to ligand protonation, structural distortions and, ultimatley, catalyst deactivation. Substantial efforts have been directed towards the development of molecular catalysts for water reduction based on abundant and affordable 3d transition metals. Such catalysts must withstand drastic electronic and structural changes from high to low redox states required for hydride formation that precedes H2 evolution. To this end, cobalt complexes have been extensively studied because of the energetically affordable stepwise conversions from 3d Co to 3d Co and back to Co– H and Co–H hydride species. [1b, 1c, 1g, 1j, 1k, 2] As such, mechanistic understanding of catalytic pathways —including those of deactivation— becomes a necessary condition to the development of robust catalysts. Our group has studied the mechanisms of several proton and water reduction cobalt catalysts, including some phenolaterich Co [N2O3] catalysts that served as the stepping stone to much improved pyridine-rich Co [N2N py 3] catalysts for water reduction that display TON > 7000 mol. 3] We have gathered evidence that some molecular catalysts such as cobalt oximes [2d] are converted into nanoparticulates through ligand hydrolysis triggered by radical-based mechanisms. Therefore, although the involvement of ligands in the catalytic cycle has been reported, we conclude that radical formation may have deleterious effects on H2 production. [5] Here we examine this issue in detail and suggest that formation of energetically equivalent valence tautomers, viz. [Co(L)] ↔ [Co(L•)] offers additional conversion pathways that lead to catalyst deactivation. In order to evaluate this hypothesis we examined the electronic and redox structure of the pseudo-octahedral [CoL(pyr)2]PF6 (1) complex, where (L ) is the doubly deprotonated form of a bis-amido pyridine ligand and pyr denotes axially coordinated pyrrolidines, as shown in Scheme 1. Complex 1 was synthesized by adapting reported procedures, where the ligand was treated under aerobic conditions with 1 equiv. of Co(OAc)2•4H2O in presence of pyrrolidine using methanol as the solvent. The formation of a microcrystalline precipitate was induced by the addition of NH4PF6. Complex 1 was thoroughly characterized using H–NMR, FTIR, ESI-MS(+), and elemental analysis (See Experimental Section for details), as well as X-ray crystallography (vide infra). As it will be discussed, this species is capable of robust water reduction followed by rapid deactivation. The cyclic voltammogram (CV) of 1 was taken in CH3CN and shows five independent redox processes (Figure 1). The processes at E1/2 = 1.34 VNHE (ΔE = 0.10 V, |Ipa/Ipc| = 1.08) and Epa = 1.94 VNHE are assigned as amido to amidyl radical oxidations (for potentials vs. Ag/AgCl and Fc/Fc see Table S1). The process at Epc = -0.32 VNHE is assigned to the Co/Co couple. 9] The process at -1.08 VNHE (ΔEp = 0.16 V, |Ipa/Ipc| = 0.84) is tentatively assigned to a Co /Co couple, while the third process at -1.79 VNHE (ΔE = 0.11 V) is attributed to a pyridine-based reduction. The CV of 1 in phosphate buffer (1 mol/L, pH 7, Figure 2) shows a catalytic wave at -0.95 VNHE in presence of 1 with concurent evolution of gas at the surface of the electrode. This corresponds to an overpotential of 0.54 V. Moreover, the onset potential of -0.95 VNHE closely resembles that of the Co /Co [] Mr. H. Baydoun, Dr. S. Mazumder, Prof. H. B. Schlegel, Prof. C. N. Verani Department of Chemistry, Wayne State University 5101 Cass Ave, Detroit, MI 48202 (USA) E-mail: cnverani@chem.wayne.edu Homepage: http://chem.wayne.edu/veranigroup/ Dr. S. Mazumder Current address: Department of Chemistry, Hofstra University, Berliner Hall, Hempstead, NY 11549 (USA) Supporting information for this article is given via a link at the end of the document. Figure 1: The CV of 1 (1 mM) in ACN. Glassy carbon, Ag/AgCl, Pt wire, TBAPF6 (0.1 M). Ferrocene is used as an internal standard. Scheme 1: Synthetic scheme of catalyst 1. 10.1002/chem.201701783 Chemistry A European Journal This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
Chemistry