Abstract:We apply hidden Markov model to concurrently collected electroencephalography‐functional magnetic resonance imaging (EEG‐fMRI) resting‐state data, to investigate differences in brain states between eyes open (EO) and eyes closed (EC) resting states. The results showed significant differences in the brain state dynamics of both EEG and fMRI states between EO and EC rest. The human brain exhibits spatio‐temporally complex activity even in the absence of external stimuli, cycling through recurring patterns of activity known as brain states. Thus far, brain state analysis has primarily been restricted to unimodal neuroimaging data sets, resulting in a limited definition of state and a poor understanding of the spatial and temporal relationships between states identified from different modalities. Here, we applied hidden Markov model (HMM) to concurrent electroencephalography‐functional magnetic resonance imaging (EEG‐fMRI) eyes open (EO) and eyes closed (EC) resting‐state data, training models on the EEG and fMRI data separately, and evaluated the models' ability to distinguish dynamics between the two rest conditions. Additionally, we employed a general linear model approach to identify the BOLD correlates of the EEG‐defined states to investigate whether the fMRI data could be used to improve the spatial definition of the EEG states. Finally, we performed a sliding window‐based analysis on the state time courses to identify slower changes in the temporal dynamics, and then correlated these time courses across modalities. We found that both models could identify expected changes during EC rest compared to EO rest, with the fMRI model identifying changes in the activity and functional connectivity of visual and attention resting‐state networks, while the EEG model correctly identified the canonical increase in alpha upon eye closure. In addition, by using the fMRI data, it was possible to infer the spatial properties of the EEG states, resulting in BOLD correlation maps resembling canonical alpha‐BOLD correlations. Finally, the sliding window analysis revealed unique fractional occupancy dynamics for states from both models, with a selection of states showing strong temporal correlations across modalities. Overall, this study highlights the efficacy of using HMMs for brain state analysis, confirms that multimodal data can be used to provide more in‐depth definitions of state and demonstrates that states defined across different modalities show similar temporal dynamics.

Critical brain dynamics in the EEG resting state

Complexity and Topographic Analysis of EEG under Normal and Simulated High Altitude Acute Hypoxia Conditions

Criticality in the Healthy Brain

The Differences among Eyes-Closed, Eyes-Open and Attention States: An EEG Study

Shared oscillatory mechanisms of alpha-band activity in prefrontal regions in eyes open and closed state using a portable EEG acquisition device

Criticality in Large-Scale Brain fMRI Dynamics Unveiled by a Novel Point Process Analysis

Open eyes and closed eyes elicit different temporal properties of brain functional networks

Faded Critical Dynamics in Adult Moyamoya Disease Revealed by EEG and Fmri.

Cortex deviates from criticality during action and deep sleep: a temporal renormalization group approach

Critical Dynamics in Spontaneous Resting-State Oscillations Are Associated With the Attention-Related P300 ERP in a Go/Nogo Task

Brain state dynamics differ between eyes open and eyes closed rest

The Difference of Brain Functional Connectivity Between Eyes-Closed and Eyes-Open Using Graph Theoretical Analysis

A quality control analysis of the resting state hypothesis via permutation entropy on EEG recordings

Modulation of brain states on fractal and oscillatory power of EEG in brain-computer interfaces

EEG brain network variability is correlated with other pathophysiological indicators of critical patients in neurology intensive care unit

Mixed signatures for subcritical dynamics in rodent hippocampus during sleep and awake epochs

Avalanche criticality in individuals, fluid intelligence, and working memory

Criticality and universality in neuronal cultures during "up" and "down" states

Scaling of the Background Brain Dynamics and Alpha Rhythm

Criticality and universality in neuronal cultures during ‘up’ and ‘down’ states

Theoretical foundations of studying criticality in the brain