Abstract:During binocular rivalry, observers can perceive only one of two competing monocular stimuli at any time. In contrast, visual phantoms involve perceptual filling-in across a gap between two collinearly aligned gratings. Here, we used psychophysics and fMRI to investigate the interactions of the neural mechanisms mediating these two phenomena. Such interactions can potentially reveal the sequence of processing in the visual pathway. We devised a novel display, which revealed that rivalry determines the outcome of phantom filling-in. One eye was shown two vertically aligned gratings, positioned one above the other, which would normally lead to perception of a visual phantom in the gap, while the other eye viewed two horizontal gratings that would normally not lead to a visual phantom. During binocular rivalry between these stimuli, subjects reported phantom filling-in only when the vertically aligned gratings were dominant. These results suggest that binocular rivalry occurs at an earlier stage of processing than phantom filling-in. We also monitored fMRI activity while subjects viewed this perceptually ambiguous display. When subjects perceived the vertically aligned gratings as dominant, increased activity was observed in retinotopic regions corresponding to the phantom location in areas V1 and V2. In contrast, when the horizontal gratings became dominant and observers failed to perceive a phantom, decreased activity was found. Our results indicate that: 1) rivalry can suppress the formation of visual phantoms and therefore likely occurs at an earlier stage of visual processing, 2) neural activity in V1 and V2 reflects the observer's conscious perception of the visual phantom suggesting filling-in occurs in these early visual areas, and 3) assuming that rivalry precedes filling-in, it follows that binocular rivalry likely occurs at a processing stage no later than V1 (cf. Polonsky et al., 2000; Tong & Engel, 2001; but see also Leopold & Logothetis, 1996). NIH grants R01-EY14202, P50-MH62196

Binocular Rivalry: A Window into Cortical Competition and Suppression

Neural Bases of Binocular Rivalry

Neural bases of binocular rivalry.

Ensemble Cortical Responses to Rival Visual Stimuli: Effect of Monocular Transient.

A Study on Binocular Rivalry Based on the Steady State Vep

Binocular Rivalry and Perceptual Filling-in of Visual Phantoms in Human Visual Cortex

Which image is in awareness during binocular rivalry? Reading perceptual status from eye movements

Nonlinear Dynamics of Binocular Rivalry: A Comparative Study

Effects of consciousness on human brain waves following binocular rivalry

Binocular Rivalry Can Fully Gate the Formation of Visual Phantoms

Temporal Characteristics of Binocular Rivalry: Visual Field Asymmetries

Dichoptic viewing methods for binocular rivalry research: prospects for large-scale clinical and genetic studies

Integration and Suppression Interact in Binocular Vision

MEG phase follows conscious perception during binocular rivalry induced by visual stream segregation.

Binocularity and Visual Search-Revisited

Source Estimation of Contrast-related Perception Based on Frequency-Tagged Binocular Rivalry.

Applications of the binocular rivalry paradigm in psychiatry

A SSVEP Stimulus System Using Time-division Sequence Signals For Binocular Rivalry Research

Role of Weak Periodic Signal in Binocular Rivalry

Investigating critical brain area for EEG-based binocular color fusion and rivalry with EEGNet

A Method for Real-time Detection of Binocular Rivalry through Electroencephalogram