Changes in Cognitive Processes upon Learning Mini-Shogi.
Takeshi Ito,Daisuke Takano,Xiaohong Wan,Keiji Tanaka
2012-01-01
Abstract:Changes in Cognitive Processes upon Learning Mini-Shogi Takeshi Ito (ito@cs.uec.ac.jp) Department of Communication Engineering and Informatics The University of Electro-Communications, 1-5-1 Chofugaoka, Chofu, Tokyo, JAPAN Daisuke Takeno (takano@minerva.cs.uec.ac.jp) Department of Communication Engineering and Informatics The University of Electro-Communications, 1-5-1 Chofugaoka, Chofu, Tokyo, 182-8585, JAPAN Xiaohong Wan (xhwan@brain.riken.jp) Laboratory for Cognitive Brain Mapping RIKEN Brain Science Institute, Hirosawa 2-1, Wako_shi, Saitama, 351-0198, JAPAN Keiji Tanaka (keiji@riken.jp) Laboratory for Cognitive Brain Mapping RIKEN Brain Science Institute, Hirosawa 2-1, Wako_shi, Saitama, 351-0198, JAPAN Abstract In this research, we investigated cognitive processes while playing Mini-Shogi through fMRI and cognitive experiments. Mini-Shogi is a Japanese chess-like game that uses a small board. In our cognitive experiment, the group of stronger Mini-Shogi players the stronger group’s total thinking time shortened and their total number of eye movements decreased. However, our investigation of search depth revealed different results from those of past research. The results of our fMRI experiment revealed that after learning, activity in the caudate nucleus increased among stronger players. The results of our experiments suggested that intuitive ability and the capacity for careful consideration are not independent. Simon showed that stronger players have bigger chunks of chess knowledge than do weaker players. Ito and others have observed cognitive differences between experts and beginners in Shogi (Japanese chess) as a follow-up to research on chess (Ito, Reijer and Matsubara, 2004). In that research, they compared the thought processes of beginners, club players, and experts during the next move task. The results are shown in the following table (Table 1). The results suggested that there were not only spatial clusters (spatial chunks) but time clusters (time chunks) involved in the experiments on chess. Table 1: The results of cognitive research on Shogi Club Beginners Experts players Recognition of a slow fast very fast position Area of eye very wide narrow movements narrow Thought time short long short Generation of a a few many a few candidate move Depth of search shallow deep more deep Keywords: Expertise; Mini-Shogi; Intuition; fMRI; Eye movement. Introduction Since developments in measurement apparatus have recently made it easier for physiological data to be measured more correctly (and in greater detail), the amount of research comparing cognitive data with physiological data is increasing. One type of such research, research on learning, not only clarifies the mechanism of intelligence but will also be useful for education. In the field of cognitive science, research examining the difference between beginners and experts using chess and puzzles has been executed. In chess, the most famous cognitive experiments have involved memorizing positions and were performed by de Groot (de Groot, 1965; de Groot & Gobet, 1996). The results of those experiments revealed that experts can memorize more chess pieces of a position quickly than beginners. As a follow-up to de Groot’s work, Chase and Simon introduced the theory of chunking to explain why expert game players perform so well in memory tasks (Chase & Simon, 1973). Chunking is the process of dividing a chess position into smaller parts that have meanings. Chase and This topic has also been researched in the field of brain science. With technological progress, measurement of brain activity came to be accomplished less via PET (positron emission tomography) and more via fMRI (functional magnetic resonance imaging). Paolo and others measured the active parts of the brain by using PET while subjects were solving chess-related problems (Paolo et al., 1994). The frontal lobes, the occipital lobes, and the left premotor area were activated when chess-related problems were considered. Atherton, Chen, and others measured which parts of the brain were activated by solving problems in chess and Go using fMRI (Atherton et al., 2003; Chen et al., 2003). The