Abstract:Spectroscopy experiments are crucial to study membrane proteins for which traditional structure determination methods still prove challenging. Double electron-electron resonance (DEER) spectroscopy experiments provide protein residue-pair distance distributions that are indicative of their conformational heterogeneity. Atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulations are another tool that have been proven to be vital to study the structural dynamics of membrane proteins such as to identify inward-open, occluded, and outward-open conformations of transporter membrane proteins, among other partially open or closed states of the protein. Yet, studies have reported that there is no direct consensus between the distributional data from DEER experiments and MD simulations, which has challenged validation of structures obtained from long-timescale simulations and using simulations to design experiments. Current coping strategies for comparisons rely on heuristics, such as mapping the nearest matching peaks between two ensembles or biased simulations. Here we examine the differences in residue-pair distance distributions arising due to the choice of membranes around the protein and covalent modification of a pair of residues to nitroxide spin labels in DEER experiments. Through comparing MD simulations of two proteins, PepTSo and LeuT-both of which have been characterized using DEER experiments previously-we show that the proteins' dynamics are similar despite the choice of the detergent micelle as a membrane mimetic in DEER experiments. On the other hand, covalently modified residues show slight local differences in their dynamics and a huge divergence when the oxygen atom pair distances between spin labeled residues are measured rather than protein backbone distances. Given the computational expense associated with pairwise MTSSL labeled MD simulations, we examine the use of biased simulations to explore the conformational dynamics of the spin labels only to reveal that such simulations alter the underlying protein dynamics. Our study identifies the main cause for the mismatch between DEER experiments and MD simulations and will accelerate the development of potential mitigation strategies to improve the match.

Oligomeric Structure of Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin in a Lipid Bilayer Environment by Combining Solid-State NMR and Long-range DEER Constraints

Determining Oligomeric Order of A Membrane Protein by Double Electron-Electron Resonance Spectroscopy

In Situ Structural Studies of Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin in the E. Coli Membrane.

Paramagnetic Relaxation Enhancement Reveals Oligomerization Interface Of A Membrane Protein

Solid-state NMR spectroscopy structure determination of a lipid-embedded heptahelical membrane protein

Solid-state NMR 13 C and 15 N Resonance Assignments of a Seven-Transmembrane Helical Protein Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin

Reconciling membrane protein simulations with experimental DEER spectroscopy data

An Exhaustive Search Algorithm to Aid NMR-Based Structure Determination of Rotationally Symmetric Transmembrane Oligomers

Structural Refinement of Proteins by Restrained Molecular Dynamics Simulations with Non-Interacting Molecular Fragments

High-resolution membrane protein structure by joint calculations with solid-state NMR and X-ray experimental data

Conformational Dynamics of a Seven Transmembrane Helical Protein Anabaena Sensory Rhodopsin Probed by Solid-State NMR.

Site-specific Solid-State NMR Detection of Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Reveals Conformational Changes in a 7-Helical Transmembrane Protein.

Quantitative analysis of sterol-modulated monomer-dimer equilibrium of the β1-adrenergic receptor by DEER spectroscopy

Combining molecular dynamics simulations with small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering data to study multi-domain proteins in solution.

Structure determination of the seven-helix transmembrane receptor sensory rhodopsin II by solution NMR spectroscopy

Rapid Determination of the Topology of Oligomeric α-Helical Membrane Proteins by Water- and Lipid-Edited Methyl NMR

Structure Determination of Supra-Molecular Assemblies by Solid-State NMR: Practical Considerations

NMR of Membrane Proteins: Beyond Crystals

Structure Determination of Challenging Protein-Peptide Complexes Combining NMR Chemical Shift Data and Molecular Dynamics Simulations

Spatial Intensity Distribution Analysis Reveals Abnormal Oligomerization of Proteins in Single Cells

Improving Olfactory Receptor Structure Modeling via Hybrid Methods