Abstract:The mechanical properties of the skin determine tissue function and regulate dermal cell behavior. Yet measuring these properties remains challenging, as evidenced by the large range of elastic moduli reported in the literature-from below one kPa to hundreds of MPa. Here, we reconcile these disparate results by dedicated experiments at both tissue and cellular length scales and by computational models considering the multiscale and multiphasic tissue structure. At the macroscopic tissue length scale, the collective behavior of the collagen fiber network under tension provides functional tissue stiffness, and its properties determine the corresponding elastic modulus (100-200 kPa). The compliant microscale environment (0.1-10 kPa), probed by atomic force microscopy, arises from the ground matrix without engaging the collagen fiber network. Our analysis indicates that indentation-based elasticity measurements, although probing tissue properties at the cell-relevant length scale, do not assess the deformation mechanisms activated by dermal cells when exerting traction forces on the extracellular matrix. Using dermal-equivalent collagen hydrogels, we demonstrate that indentation measurements of tissue stiffness do not correlate with the behavior of embedded dermal fibroblasts. These results provide a deeper understanding of tissue mechanics across length scales with important implications for skin mechanobiology and tissue engineering. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Measuring the mechanical properties of the skin is essential for understanding dermal cell mechanobiology and designing tissue-engineered skin substitutes. However, previous results reported for the elastic modulus of skin vary by six orders of magnitude. We show that two distinct deformation mechanisms, related to the tension-compression nonlinearity of the collagen fiber network, can explain the large variations in elastic moduli. Furthermore, we show that microscale indentation, which is frequently used to assess the stiffness perceived by cells, fails to engage the fiber network, and therefore cannot predict the behavior of dermal fibroblasts in stiffness-tunable fibrous hydrogels. This has important implications for how to measure and interpret the mechanical properties of soft tissues across length scales.

Computational Models for the Determination of Depth-Dependent Mechanical Properties of Skin with a Soft, Flexible Measurement Device.

A New Model Based on the In-Plane Deformation for the Conformal Piezoelectric Systems for Characterization of Soft Tissue Modulus

Skin-Integrated Electromechanical Systems for Characterization of Deep Tissue Biomechanics

A biphasic multilayer computational model of human skin

Thermal analysis of ultrathin, compliant sensors for characterization of the human skin

Flexible and Stretchable 3ω Sensors for Thermal Characterization of Human Skin

Multiscale mechanical analysis of the elastic modulus of skin

A quadriphasic mechanical model of the human dermis

An Electronic Skin Strain Sensor for Adaptive Angle Calculation

In Vivo Measurement of the Mechanical Properties of Facial Soft Tissue Using a Bi-Layer Material Model

Ultrathin Conformal Devices for Precise and Continuous Thermal Characterization of Human Skin

A three-dimensionally architected electronic skin mimicking human mechanosensation

Three-Dimensional Finite Element Analysis of a Novel Silicon Based Tactile Sensor with Elastic Cover.

Poromechanical modelling of the time-dependent response of in vivo human skin during extension

On the Living Body Face Skin Mechanical Properties in Situ Measurement

In vivo measurement of the anisotropic mechanical properties of human skin by indentation test

Design and Validation of a DMA-inspired Device for In-Vivo Measurement of Human Skin Mechanics: a Finite Element Analysis Approach

Characterization of the mechanical properties of skin by inverse analysis combined with the indentation test

In vivo mechanical characterization of human facial skin combining curved surface imaging and indentation techniques.

Mechanical characterization of human skin-A non-invasive digital twin approach using vibration-response integrated with numerical methods

Miniaturized electromechanical devices for the characterization of the biomechanics of deep tissue