The Application of GKT Paradigm in Determining the Criminal Suspects: An ERP Lie Detection Study
Xin Liu,Dongtao Wei,Qinglin Zhang,Yinghui Guo
DOI: https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.20180323
2018-01-01
Abstract:Criminal crime has become a universal social problem faced by all countries. With the concealment of criminal behavior and the diversification of criminal means, the traditional methods of investigation have become increasingly unable to meet the needs of the current criminal investigation. Therefore, an effective and reliable lie detection technique is urgently needed to meet the current severe situation of combating crime. This study adopted GKT (Guilty knowledge test) paradigm, with the suspect as the object, with real crime scene material, investigated the validity and reliability of the ERP index (P300\CNV) which was associated with lie detection during real criminal environment. Twenty-six subjects participated in the present study, which were all male and real criminal suspects. And the age range was 19-46 year old. The GKT paradigm involved three stimuli: target stimulus, probe stimulus and irreverent stimulus. Those stimuli were all presented as pictures, and the emergence proportion of the target, probe and irrelevant stimuli were 1:1:4. Participants were required to respond to whether the stimulus they had ever seen before a key prompt appeared immediately. At the same time, EEG activity was recorded. Repeated measures of variance analysis were performed on the behavior data (accuracy and response times (RTs) ) and the ERP index (P300 and CNV), separately. Behavior results showed that, the accuracy of target stimuli were significantly smaller than probe stimuli and irreverent stimuli while the accuracy of probe stimulus and irrelevant stimulus was not significant. In addition, the RTs of probe stimuli were significantly smaller than target stimuli and irreverent stimuli, whereas the RTs of target stimulus was greater than irrelevant stimulus, but not significant. Moreover, the ERP results showed that, compared with target stimuli and irreverent stimuli, the P300 (400-500 ms, localized in Fz、Cz、Pz、Oz、POz、FCz) amplitude of the probe stimuli was greater than the target stimulus and irrelevant stimulus, whereas the P300 amplitude of target stimulus was significantly greater than the irrelevant stimulus. The CNV (800～1700 ms, localized in Fz、Cz、Pz、Oz、POz、FCz) amplitude of the irrelevant stimulus was significantly lower than the amplitude of the probe stimulus and target stimulus, whereas the difference between the probe stimulus and target stimulus was not significant. Furthermore, bootstrap method was used to calculate the detection rate with P300 peak value as the index, and the result found that the detection rate of P300 was 92.5％. Taken together, these findings showed three conclusions. First, ERP lie detection technology was applicable to lie detection in the field of criminal investigation and the GKT paradigm could indeed induce the P300 and CNV components. Second, compared with CNV, P300 was a reliable lie detection index, which could effectively detect the details of criminal, and had higher detection rate and better stability, further promoting the application of ERP lie detection technology in criminal investigation. Finally, as a lie-detection index, the validity of the CNV component needed to be tested in the future, and its generation might require certain conditions.