Biofilm Fueled by Serpentinization Physiological Differentiation within a Single-Species 2011
W. Brazelton,M. Mehta,D. Kelley,J. Baross
Abstract:Carbonate chimneys at the Lost City hydrothermal field are coated in biofilms dominated by a single phylotype of archaea known as Lost City Methanosarcinales. In this study, we have detected surprising physiological complexity in singlespecies biofilms, which is typically indicative of multispecies biofilm communities. Multiple cell morphologies were visible within the biofilms by transmission electron microscopy, and some cells contained intracellular membranes that may facilitate methane oxidation. Both methane production and oxidation were detected at 70 to 80°C and pH 9 to 10 in samples containing the single-species biofilms. Both processes were stimulated by the presence of hydrogen (H2), indicating that methane production and oxidation are part of a syntrophic interaction. Metagenomic data included a sequence encoding AMP-forming acetyl coenzyme A synthetase, indicating that acetate may play a role in the methane-cycling syntrophy. A wide range of nitrogen fixation genes were also identified, many of which were likely acquired via lateral gene transfer (LGT). Our results indicate that cells within these single-species biofilms may have differentiated into multiple physiological roles to form multicellular communities linked by metabolic interactions and LGT. Communities similar to these Lost City biofilms are likely to have existed early in the evolution of life, and we discuss how the multicellular characteristics of ancient hydrogen-fueled biofilm communities could have stimulated ecological diversification, as well as unity of biochemistry, during the earliest stages of cellular evolution. IMPORTANCE Our previous work at the Lost City hydrothermal field has shown that its carbonate chimneys host microbial biofilms dominated by a single uncultivated “species” of archaea. In this paper, we integrate evidence from these previous studies with new data on the metabolic activity and cellular morphology of these archaeal biofilms. We conclude that the archaeal biofilm must contain cells that are physiologically and possibly genetically differentiated with respect to each other. These results are especially interesting considering the possibility that the first cells originated and evolved in hydrothermal systems similar to Lost City. Received 12 June 2011 Accepted 7 July 2011 Published 26 July 2011 Citation Brazelton WJ, Mehta MP, Kelley DS, Baross JA. 2011. Physiological differentiation within a single-species biofilm fueled by serpentinization. mBio 2(4):e00127-11. doi: 10.1128/mBio.00127-11. Editor Jo Handelsman, Yale University Copyright © 2011 Brazelton et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported License, which permits unrestricted noncommercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. Address correspondence to John A. Baross, jbaross@u.washington.edu. The set of geochemical reactions known as serpentinization presents unique opportunities and challenges for biological communities, but little is known about the adaptations required of organisms that inhabit serpentinization-dominated habitats. Serpentinization is exothermic anywhere water reacts with the mineral olivine, and it results in warm, alkaline fluids and abiotic synthesis of hydrogen (H2), methane, and larger hydrocarbons (1, 2). It typically occurs in ultramafic oceanic crust and is also expected to occur on other planetary bodies where liquid water and olivine are present (3). Alkaline hydrothermal systems driven by serpentinization were probably widespread on the seafloor of the ancient Archean ocean, and H2 and methane generated by serpentinization may have supported the earliest biological communities (4–7). A modern example of such an ecosystem is the Lost City hydrothermal field, where microbial biofilm communities attached to the carbonate chimneys are fueled by 90°C, pH 9 to 11, serpentinization-derived fluids rich in H2 and methane (1). Therefore, the Lost City ecosystem provides an opportunity to directly investigate geochemical and biological processes thought to be important in the early evolution of life. The densely populated (up to 109 cells/g carbonate) mucilaginous biofilms within Lost City carbonate chimneys appear to be dominated by a single “species” of archaea. In the hottest and highest-pH zones of actively venting chimneys, nearly 100% of the archaeal sequences in 16S rRNA gene clone libraries and tag pyrosequencing data sets belong to a single phylotype referred to as Lost City Methanosarcinales (LCMS) (8, 9). Furthermore, a FISH (fluorescent in situ hybridization) probe specific to the LCMS phylotype comprises up to 32.5% of the cells in the interior of actively venting chimneys. A FISH probe universal to bacteria detected only 4.2% of the cells in the same sample, so the LCMS phylotype represents ~80% of the cells detectable by FISH (8). The bacteria in these samples are dominated by taxa expected to be mesophilic and aerobic or microaerophilic and therefore would not occupy the same hot, anoxic zones as the members of the order Methanosarcinales (9, 10). Such extreme dominance by a single species is remarkable, especially considering the longevity of the Lost City hydrothermal field. Radiometric dating of Lost City chimneys indicates that hydrothermal activity has been ongoing for at least 100,000 years and possibly up to 1 million years (11, RESEARCH ARTICLE July/August 2011 Volume 2 Issue 4 e00127-11 ® mbio.asm.org 1 m b.asm .rg on July 6, 2011 P ubished by m b.asm .rg D ow nladed fom 12). Although we cannot know whether the LCMS phylotype has been present throughout that history, it has been found to dominate actively venting chimneys at least ~100 years old (9). In general, ecosystem stability is thought to require high biological diversity (13). If this model applies to the Lost City ecosystem, then two possible explanations for the extremely low diversity of the Lost City archaeal biofilms are apparent. One possibility is that the low-diversity biofilms are inherently unstable but do not experience environmental perturbations or do not experience competition. A potential example of this scenario is a deep mine ecosystem apparently consisting of a single bacterial species (14). The extreme energy limitation of this habitat, along with its isolation, may contribute to ecological simplicity/stability by reducing the number of available competitors. This explanation is consistent with the long-lived nature (compared to other hydrothermal systems) and physiological constraints of Lost City chimneys, but significant changes in chimney fluid chemistry, temperature, and mineralogy do occur over time (15). Therefore, the chimney biofilms are not completely protected from environmental perturbations, but the unusual stability and extreme conditions of their habitat may contribute to their low diversity. A second explanation (that is not mutually exclusive with respect to the first) is that the archaeal biofilms harbor more ecologically relevant diversity than is apparent in molecular surveys of 16S rRNA genes. It is now commonly accepted that organisms with nearly identical 16S rRNA genes may differ greatly in genomic content and physiological characteristics. For example, Vibrio splendidus isolates with 99% 16S rRNA gene sequence similarity can have widely different genome sizes and contain extensive heterogeneity in protein-coding genes (16). Hunt et al. (17) have suggested that these isolates represent recent or ongoing sympatric speciation events resulting from fine partitioning of resources. Niche partitioning among closely related species is particularly well documented for cyanobacteria. Several studies have delineated multiple cyanobacterial “ecotypes” that inhabit distinct regions within oceanic water columns (18, 19) or within hot spring microbial mats (20). Although the 16S rRNA genes of cyanobacterial ecotypes may be highly similar, the genomic contents can vary widely (21–23). In another study, metagenomic sequencing revealed two coexisting strains of “Cenarchaeum symbiosum” (an archaeal symbiont of marine sponges) with 99% 16S rRNA gene sequence similarity (24). The authors conclude that the two strains may occupy different niches within the host sponge or else participate in a metabolic interdependence that maintains their coexistence. Recent evidence suggests that the LCMS phylotype also comprises multiple closely related, coexisting strains. Tag pyrosequencing of the V6 hypervariable region of the 16S rRNA gene of natural LCMS biofilm populations revealed hundreds of very rare sequences that differed by 1 to 2 bp from the most common sequence, possibly representing a dormant pool of variants (9). Clone library sequencing of the intergenic transcribed spacer (ITS) region between the 16S and 23S rRNA genes of LCMS biofilms revealed multiple ITS genotypes associated with the same V6 genotype (25). The relative abundance of its genotypes differed among samples, suggesting a possible ecological signature. In this paper, we present additional evidence for microdiversity within the LCMS biofilm population in the form of syntrophic physiological activity, cell morphological differentiation, and functional gene diversity. In particular, we focus on the ability of LCMS biofilms to generate or oxidize methane. LCMS has resisted laboratory cultivation because of the difficulty in replicating its in situ environmental conditions and/or because its growth rate is too low to be detected by typical laboratory experiments. Consequently, the physiology of LCMS is unknown. All known members of the order Methanosarcinales either generate or oxidize methane; therefore, LCMS cells are presumed to utilize either H2 or methane, both of which are present at high concentrations (1 to 14 mmol/kg and 1 to 2 mmol/kg, respectively) in Lost City hydrothermal fluids. Carbon d