Abstract:The two key steps for analyzing proteomic data generated by high-resolution MS are database searching and postprocessing. While the two steps are interrelated, studies on their combinatory effects and the optimization of these procedures have not been adequately conducted. Here, we investigated the performance of three popular search engines (SEQUEST, Mascot, and MS Amanda) in conjunction with five filtering approaches, including respective score-based filtering, a group-based approach, local false discovery rate (LFDR), PeptideProphet, and Percolator. A total of eight data sets from various proteomes (e.g., E. coli, yeast, and human) produced by various instruments with high-accuracy survey scan (MS1) and high- or low-accuracy fragment ion scan (MS2) (LTQ-Orbitrap, Orbitrap-Velos, Orbitrap-Elite, Q-Exactive, Orbitrap-Fusion, and Q-TOF) were analyzed. It was found combinations involving Percolator achieved markedly more peptide and protein identifications at the same FDR level than the other 12 combinations for all data sets. Among these, combinations of SEQUEST-Percolator and MS Amanda-Percolator provided slightly better performances for data sets with low-accuracy MS2 (ion trap or IT) and high accuracy MS2 (Orbitrap or TOF), respectively, than did other methods. For approaches without Percolator, SEQUEST-group performs the best for data sets with MS2 produced by collision-induced dissociation (CID) and IT analysis; Mascot-LFDR gives more identifications for data sets generated by higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD) and analyzed in Orbitrap (HCD-OT) and in Orbitrap Fusion (HCD-IT); MS Amanda-Group excels for the Q-TOF data set and the Orbitrap Velos HCD-OT data set. Therefore, if Percolator was not used, a specific combination should be applied for each type of data set. Moreover, a higher percentage of multiple-peptide proteins and lower variation of protein spectral counts were observed when analyzing technical replicates using Percolator-associated combinations; therefore, Percolator enhanced the reliability for both identification and quantification. The analyses were performed using the specific programs embedded in Proteome Discoverer, Scaffold, and an in-house algorithm (BuildSummary). These results provide valuable guidelines for the optimal interpretation of proteomic results and the development of fit-for-purpose protocols under different situations.

A Graph-Based Filtering Method for Top-Down Mass Spectral Identification.

A Spectrum Graph-Based Protein Sequence Filtering Algorithm for Proteoform Identification by Top-Down Mass Spectrometry.

A Novel Spectral Library Workflow to Enhance Protein Identifications

Evaluation of Top-Down Mass Spectral Identification with Homologous Protein Sequences

Fast peak error correction algorithms for proteoform identification using top-down tandem mass spectra

Proteoform Characterization Based On Top-Down Mass Spectrometry

Comparing Top-Down Proteoform Identification: Deconvolution, PrSM Overlap, and PTM Detection

Evaluation of Bottom-Up and Top-Down Mass Spectrum Identifications with Different Customized Protein Sequences Databases

Ptop 1.0: A High-Accuracy and High-Efficiency Search Engine for Intact Protein Identification

Optimization of Search Engines and Postprocessing Approaches to Maximize Peptide and Protein Identification for High-Resolution Mass Data

Spectral Quality Assessment and Application for Gel-Based Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption Ionization-Time of Flight Tandem Mass Spectrometer

A Suffix Tree Approach to the Interpretation of Tandem Mass Spectra: Applications to Peptides of Non-Specific Digestion and Post-Translational Modifications.

TopLib: Building and searching top-down mass spectral libraries for proteoform identification

New and automated MSn approaches for top-down identification of modified proteins

A Multi-stage Spectral Alignment Strategy for Unrestrictive PTM Peptide Identification

Algorithmic study on mass spectrometry and proteomics

De Novo Sequencing Assisted Approach for Characterizing Mixture MS/MS Spectra

Generating Peptide Sequence Tags for Peptide Identification via Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Generating Protein Sequence Tags by Combining Cone and Conventional Collision Induced Dissociation in a Quadrupole Time-of-flight Mass Spectrometer

An Evaluation for Cross-Species Proteomics Research by Publicly Available Expressed Sequence Tag Database Search Using Tandem Mass Spectral Data

Speeding up tandem mass spectrometry based database searching by peptide and spectrum indexing.