A comparative study: Ultrasound-guided leverage reduction with internal fixation using Kirschner wires or elastic stable intramedullary nailing for severely displaced radial neck fractures in children
Ji Wu,Xiantao Shen,Ping Zhang,Rui Zhou,Yanhong Li,Bingrong Tang,Xing Wu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/md.0000000000035507
IF: 1.6
2024-02-10
Medicine
Abstract:Fractures of the proximal radius constitute a mere 1% of all fractures and between 4.5 to 21% of pediatric elbow fractures, with radial neck fractures (RNFs) accounting for the majority of these cases. [ 1 ] Although minimally displaced RNFs typically respond well to non-operative treatment, severely displaced or angulated fractures, such as Judet type III, IV, O'Brien type II, III, or AO type 21r–E/1.1 III,21r–E/2.1 III, 21r–M/3.1 III, often result in unsatisfactory outcomes when managed non-operatively. [ 2–5 ] Most authors advocate for closed reduction for fractures with angulation >30°; however, achieving this reduction is challenging for severely angulated fractures. Open reduction permits anatomical reduction but involves a high risk of avascular necrosis of the radial head, and whenever possible closed reduction is preferred by the majority of surgeons. [ 6 , 7 ] Moreover, after open reduction, the results are often cited as fair or poor. [ 8 ] Percutaneous leverage reduction and internal fixation techniques have been further developed since their first introduction by Feray in 1969, offering a less invasive alternative. [ 9 ] Métaizeau [ 10 ] utilized intramedullary nailing for the reduction and fixation of radial neck fractures. While these minimally invasive procedures have been proved effective in many instances, challenges may still arise, particularly in cases of complete displacement. Guaranteeing anatomical or near-anatomical reduction is indeed challenging for completely displaced fractures. Ultrasound, increasingly used in pediatric musculoskeletal pathology evaluation, has demonstrated reliable diagnostic performance for long bone fractures in children when compared to conventional radiography. [ 11 , 12 ] Additionally, several studies have confirmed the utility of ultrasound in assessing reduction adequacy. [ 13 , 14 ] In literature, some studies [ 15–17 ] have shown that ultrasound-guided diagnosis is reliable in detecting fractures of RNFs. Nevertheless, to our knowledge, we know of no previous studies reported in the literature comparing 2 different ultrasonography (US)-guided closed reduction and fixation methods in managing displaced radial neck fractures in children.
medicine, general & internal