Abstract:BACKGROUND: Emerging studies have investigated potential cardiovascular and respiratory health impacts from the use of personal-level intervention equipment against air pollution exposure. The objective of this systematic review is to assess the efficacy of personal-level air pollution intervention on mitigating adverse health effects from air pollution exposure by using portable air cleaner or wearing respirator.METHODS: In this systematic review, we searched PubMed and Web of Science for published literatures up to May 31, 2020, focusing on personal-level air pollution intervention studies. Among these studies, we investigated the impacts on cardio-respiratory responses to the use of these interventions. The intervention of review interest was the use of personal-level equipment against air pollution, including using portable air cleaner indoors or wearing respirator outdoors. The outcome of review interest was impacts on cardio-respiratory health endpoints following interventions, including level changes in blood pressure, heart rate variability (HRV), lung function, and biomarkers of inflammation and oxidative stress. Weighted mean differences or percent changes were pooled in meta-analyses for these health endpoints. The heterogeneity across studies was assessed using the Cochran's Q-statistic test, and the individual study quality was assessed using the Cochrane risk of bias tool version 2 (RoB 2). We further applied the Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) method to evaluate the certainty of evidence.RESULTS: From systematic literature search and screening, we identified 29 related eligible intervention studies, including 21 studies on indoor portable air cleaner use and 8 studies on respirator use. For portable air cleaner intervention, we observed suggestive evidence of beneficial changes on cardio-respiratory health endpoints. Collectively in these studies, we found significantly beneficial changes of 2.01% decreases (95% CI: 0.50%, 3.52%) in systolic blood pressure, as well as non-significantly beneficial changes of 3.04% increases (95% CI: -2.65%, 8.74%) in reactive hyperemia index and 0.24% increases (95% CI: -0.82%, 1.31%) in forced expiratory volume in 1 s. We also observed non-significant reductions in levels of inflammation and oxidative stress biomarkers, including C-reactive protein, interleukin-6, fibrinogen, fractional exhaled nitric oxide and malondialdehyde. For respirator intervention, we observed some beneficial changes on cardiovascular health endpoints, such as significant increases in HRV parameters [SDNN (2.20%, 95% CI: 0.54%, 3.86%)], as well as non-significant decreases in blood pressure [SBP (0.63 mmHg, 95% CI: -0.39, 1.66)]; however, no sufficient data were available for meta-analyses on lung function and biomarkers. RoB 2 assessments suggested that most intervention studies were with a moderate to high overall risk of bias. The certainty of evidence for intervention outcome pairs was graded very low for either portable air cleaner or respirator intervention. The common reasons to downgrade study evidence included loss to follow-up, lack of blinding, lack of washout period, small sample size, and high heterogeneity across studies.CONCLUSIONS: The uses of indoor portable air cleaner and respirator could contribute to some beneficial changes on cardiovascular health, but with much limited evidence on respiratory health. Low certainty of the overall study evidence shed light on future research for larger sample size trials with more rigorous study design.

Cardiopulmonary Effects of Overnight Indoor Air Filtration in Healthy Non-Smoking Adults: A Double-Blind Randomized Crossover Study.

Air Pollution and Pulmonary Health: Effects of Short-Term Indoor Air Quality Intervention with Portable Air Purifier

Cardiorespiratory Responses of Air Filtration: A Randomized Crossover Intervention Trial in Seniors Living in Beijing: Beijing Indoor Air Purifier StudY, BIAPSY.

Effects of Air Purification of Indoor PM2.5 on the Cardiorespiratory Biomarkers in Young Healthy Adults.

Cardiopulmonary Benefits of Reducing Indoor Particles of Outdoor Origin

Cardiovascular Benefits of Short-Term Indoor Air Filtration Intervention in Elderly Living in Beijing: an Extended Analysis of BIAPSY Study.

Effectiveness of Air Purifier Intervention in Beijing - A Panel Study

Effects of air purification of indoor PM 2.5 on the cardiorespiratory biomarkers in young healthy adults

An Extended Analysis of Cardiovascular Benefits of Indoor Air Filtration Intervention among Elderly:A Randomized Crossover Trial(beijing Indoor Air Purifier Study,biapsy)

Sensitive inflammatory biomarkers of acute fine particulate matter exposure among healthy young adults: Findings from a randomized, double-blind crossover trial on air filtration

Inflammatory cytokines and DNA methylation in healthy young adults exposure to fine particulate matter: A randomized, double-blind crossover trial of air filtration

Cardiorespiratory responses in healthy young adults with exposure to indoor airborne PAEs: A randomized, crossover trial of air purification

The Health Effects of Wearing Facemasks on Cardiopulmonary System of Healthy Young Adults: A Double-Blinded, Randomized Crossover Trial.

Pulmonary Benefits of Intervention with Air Cleaner among Schoolchildren in Beijing: A Randomized Double-Blind Crossover Study

Cardiorespiratory responses to fine particles during ambient PM<sub>2.5</sub> pollution waves: Findings from a randomized crossover trial in young healthy adults

The effect of using personal-level indoor air cleaners and respirators on biomarkers of cardiorespiratory health: a systematic review

Different Cardiorespiratory Effects of Indoor Air Pollution Intervention with Ionization Air Purifier: Findings from a Randomized, Double-Blind Crossover Study among School Children in Beijing.

Acute Effects of Ambient PM2.5 on Lung Function among Schoolchildren.

Cardiovascular Effects of Wearing Respirators Against Particulate Matter: A Randomized Crossover Trial

Short-Term Effects of Carbonaceous Components in PM2.5 on Pulmonary Function: A Panel Study of 37 Chinese Healthy Adults

Effects of Indoor Air Purification Intervention on Blood Pressure, Blood‑oxygen Saturation, and Heart Rate Variability: A Double-Blinded Cross-over Randomized Controlled Trial of Healthy Young Adults