From quality markers to data mining and intelligence assessment: A smart quality-evaluation strategy for traditional Chinese medicine based on quality markers

Gang Bai,Tiejun Zhang,Yuanyuan Hou,Guoyu Ding,Min Jiang,Guoan Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.phymed.2018.01.017

IF: 6.656

2018-01-01

Phytomedicine

Abstract:Image, graphical abstract

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

From biological potency absorbed components to artificial intelligence mining: A review of analytical strategies for the discovery and validation of quality marker in traditional Chinese medicine in the past decade

Ziting Li,Yi Dai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1097/gscm.0000000000000033

2024-10-07

Abstract:Quality control of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) is fundamental to ensuring its clinical efficacy, with TCM formulas being the primary form used in clinical practice. Current quality control methods for TCM formulas often rely on pharmacopoeial standards for individual medicinal materials, typically encompassing only characteristic or partial active ingredients. These methods fail to fully reflect the clinical efficacy of TCM formulas. Consequently, exploring the multiple efficacious components in TCM formulas and establishing the correlation between multi-component content and efficacy has become an urgent issue in the modern quality assessment of TCM formulas. The quality marker (Q-marker) has emerged as a crucial standard in this field, achieving notable success in recent years. This paper reviews recent progress in the development of the Q-marker system in TCM by highlighting strategies based on the correlation between efficacy and constituents, using analytical techniques to investigate the material basis and efficacy of TCM. However, the aforementioned methods inevitably involve human selection factors. With the widespread application of artificial intelligence (AI) learning algorithms, it is now possible to develop a modern quality evaluation method for the multi-component “efficacy-quality” correlation in TCM formulas. This approach leverages AI techniques to explore novel and quantifiable methods for scientific and rational quality control in TCM formulas. In this paper, important future directions and questions in this field are also discussed.
Multimodal integrated strategy for the discovery and identification of quality markers in traditional Chinese medicine

Xiaoyan Lu,Yanyan Jin,Yuzhen Wang,Yunlong Chen,Xiaohui Fan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpha.2022.05.001

Abstract:With the modernization and internationalization of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM), the requirement for quality control has increased. The quality marker (Q-marker) is an important standard in this field and has been implemented with remarkable success in recent years. However, the establishment of Q-markers remains fragmented and the process lacks systematicity, resulting in inconsistent quality control and insufficient correlation with clinical efficacy and safety of TCM. This review introduces four multimodal integrated approaches that contribute to the discovery of more comprehensive and accurate Q-markers, thus aiding in the establishment of new quality control patterns based on the characteristics and principles of TCM. These include the whole-process quality control strategy, chemical-activity-based screening method, efficacy, safety, and consistent combination strategy, and TCM theory-guided approach. Furthermore, methodologies and representative examples of these strategies are described, and important future directions and questions in this field are also proposed.
Discriminant Analysis of "Q-Markers" of Traditional Chinese Medical Injections——Taking Dan Hong Injection as a Model

Jing Yang,Zhenzuo Jiang,Xin Chai,Yi Wang,Buchang Zhao,Xiaoping Zhao,Yuefei Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.11842/wst.2016.12.005

2016-01-01

Abstract:Quality control of traditional Chinese medicine is of great importance to ensure its safety and effectiveness in clinic,and is also an obstacle impeding the modernization of traditional Chinese medicine.Though,the complexity of traditional Chinese medicine resulted in some relative weakness of quality standard researches.The critical point need addressing is to establish a sound quality standard system conforming to the characteristics of traditional Chinese medicine in the process of the modernization of Chinese medicine.In this paper,in regard to Dan Hong injection,discriminant strategy of "Q-Markers" from traditional Chinese medicine injection was clarified from three aspects:what ingredients,which to control and how to control,providing a new vision in the field of the quality standard researches of traditional Chinese medicine.
A quality-comprehensive-evaluation-index-based model for evaluating traditional Chinese medicine quality

Jia Chen,Lin-Fu Li,Zhao-Zhou Lin,Xian-Long Cheng,Feng Wei,Shuang-Cheng Ma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13020-023-00782-0

IF: 4.546

2023-07-29

Chinese Medicine

Abstract:Evaluating traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) quality is a powerful method to ensure TCM safety. TCM quality evaluation methods primarily include characterization evaluations and separate physical, chemical, and biological evaluations; however, these approaches have limitations. Nevertheless, researchers have recently integrated evaluation methods, advancing the emergence of frontier research tools, such as TCM quality markers (Q-markers). These studies are largely based on biological activity, with weak correlations between the quality indices and quality. However, these TCM quality indices focus on the individual efficacies of single bioactive components and, therefore, do not accurately represent the TCM quality. Conventionally, provenance, place of origin, preparation, and processing are the key attributes influencing TCM quality. In this study, we identified TCM-attribute-based quality indices and developed a comprehensive multiweighted multi-index-based TCM quality composite evaluation index (QCEI) for grading TCM quality.

pharmacology & pharmacy,integrative & complementary medicine
A Novel Fingerprint Method for Quality Evaluation of Chinese Medicinal Plants Based on Analytical Data Visualization

Jie Yu,Yong-jiang Wu,Yi-yu Cheng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3321/j.issn:1001-5302.2002.02.005

2002-01-01

Abstract:OBJECTIVE:To investigate new method for evaluating the quality of Chinese Medicinal Plants (CMP).METHOD:A visualization technique for representing instrumental analytical data was developed by applying the fundamental of Data Visualization, with Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and spatial projection transformation, original IR spectral data were projected into a low-dimensional subspace so that the dimensionality of original data space was decreased and tiny fingerprint features were extracted. The data set in the subspace was visualized by means of two-dimensional grayscale images. Consequently, the characteristic fingerprint for appraising the quality of CMP was obtained.RESULT:42 mulberry root-bark samples from three different quality classes were identified with the proposed method, which showed that the fingerprint images had satisfactory resolution and classification accuracy as high as 90.5%.CONCLUSION:The proposed method is a useful technique for appraising the quality of CMP.
Research progress on quality markers of traditional Chinese medicine

Hongbing Zhang,Yu Zhang,Tiejun Zhang,Changxiao Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpba.2022.114588

IF: 3.571

2022-03-01

Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis

Abstract:The quality of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) is the lifeline for the development of TCM industry, but research work on this topic is seriously fragmented due to the lack of systematic thinking. Quality markers (Q-markers) are a new concept in TCM quality control. According to the characteristics of TCM system, such as biological attributes, manufacturing process, and compatibility theory, these markers take into account the correlation among effectiveness, material basis, and quality control landmark components and create a new model of TCM quality research. This paper reviews the research pathway and practice on TCM Q-markers in recent years and reports selected examples of case studies. It discusses the application of Q-markers to TCM quality traceability system and industry supervision. Results will provide references for further in-depth research on Q-markers to improve the whole-process quality control level of TCM.

pharmacology & pharmacy,chemistry, analytical
Approaches to establish Q-markers for the quality standards of traditional Chinese medicines

Wenzhi Yang,Yibei Zhang,Wanying Wu,Luqi Huang,Dean Guo,Changxiao Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apsb.2017.04.012

IF: 14.903

2017-07-01

Acta Pharmaceutica Sinica B

Abstract:Traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) has played a pivotal role in maintaining the health of Chinese people and is now gaining increasing acceptance around the global scope. However, TCM is confronting more and more concerns with respect to its quality. The intrinsic "multicomponent and multitarget" feature of TCM necessitates the establishment of a unique quality and bioactivity evaluation system, which is different from that of the Western medicine. However, TCM is investigated essentially as "herbal medicine" or "natural product", and the pharmacopoeia quality monographs are actually chemical-markers-based, which can ensure the consistency only in the assigned chemical markers, but, to some extent, have deviated from the basic TCM theory. A concept of "quality marker" (Q-marker), following the "property-effect-component" theory, is proposed. The establishment of Q-marker integrates multidisciplinary technologies like natural products chemistry, analytical chemistry, bionics, chemometrics, pharmacology, systems biology, and pharmacodynamics, etc. Q-marker-based fingerprint and multicomponent determination conduce to the construction of more scientific quality control system of TCM. This review delineates the background, definition, and properties of Q-marker, and the associated technologies applied for its establishment. Strategies and approaches for establishing Q-marker-based TCM quality control system are presented and highlighted with a few TCM examples.

pharmacology & pharmacy
Data Quality in Traditional Chinese Medicine

Yi Feng,Zhaohui Wu,Huajun Chen,Tong Yu,Yuxin Mao,Xiaohong Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/bmei.2008.268

2008-01-01

Abstract:Data quality is a key issue in medical informatics and bioinformatics. Although many researches could be found that discuss data quality in the area of health care and medicine, few literature exist that particularly focuses on data quality in the field of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM). Due to the high domain- specificity of data quality, it is of essential necessity to identify key dimensions of data quality in TCM. In this paper, based on TCM practice in past years, three data quality aspects are highlighted as key dimensions, including representation granularity, representation consistency, and completeness. Moreover, practical methods and techniques to handle data quality problems in these dimensions are also provided, showing how to enhance data quality in TCM field.
A New Concept on Quality Marker for Quality Assessment and Process Control of Chinese Medicines

Chang-xiao Liu,Yi-yu Cheng,De-an Guo,Tie-jun Zhang,Ya-zhuo Li,Wen-bin Hou,Lu-qi Huang,Hai-yu Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S1674-6384(17)60070-4

2017-01-01

Chinese Herbal Medicines

Abstract:Chinese medicine (CM) is the most typical conventional therapy compared with any other traditional or alternative medicine systems. The active components of CMs are either primary or secondary metabolites generated by metabolic and biosynthetic enzymes in plants, protecting the plants from environmental stress. The characteristics of these metabolites are diverse, complicated and unique. In this paper, current approaches for quality assessment were extensively reviewed, a new concept of quality marker (Q-marker) was then proposed for CM quality assessment. Additionally, definition of the Q-marker, as well as the relevant methods, were discussed, on the basis of the biosynthetic pathways of secondary metabolites and source of biological active components. Study design of Q-marker is complex system for quality assessment and production process control of CM products with transitivity and traceability. Therefore, the system with characteristics of transmission and traceability is expected to be established for regulation of quality. Upon the concept which the transitivity and traceability in the quality assessment and production process control covered the entire process, such as raw materials, decoction slices, processing, extraction and production can be further enhanced. The transitivity and traceability will inevitably require close attention to “who, what, where, when, and why” details at each stage of Q-markers of CM production form raw materials to patent product. The establishing quality standards are enablers of many and various transitivity and traceability solutions, not a solution in them. It means that the transitivity and traceability system is readily link between products and across borders in quality. According to the thinking mode and methods of investigation on quality assessment of CM product, we focus on the entire process, in terms of safety and effectiveness and quality control. The standard preparation of CM or CM decoction is not only the basis for study of Q-marker, but also the basis for transmission and traceability of the quality of CM product.
Quality transitivity and traceability system of herbal medicine products based on quality markers

Changxiao Liu,De-An Guo,Liang Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.phymed.2018.03.006

IF: 6.656

2018-05-15

Phytomedicine

Abstract:Background: Due to a variety of factors to affect the herb quality, the existing quality management model is unable to evaluate the process control. The development of the concept of "quality marker" (Q-marker) lays basis for establishing an independent process quality control system for herbal products. Hypothesis/purpose: To ensure the highest degree of safety, effectiveness and quality process control of herbal products, it is aimed to establish a quality transitivity and traceability system of quality and process control from raw materials to finished herbal products. Study design: Based on the key issues and challenges of quality assessment, the current status of quality and process controls from raw materials to herbal medicinal products listed in Pharmacopoeia were analyzed and the research models including discovery and identification of Q-markers, analysis and quality management of risk evaluation were designed. Methods: Authors introduced a few new technologies and methodologies, such as DNA barcoding, chromatographic technologies, fingerprint analysis, chemical markers, bio-responses, risk management and solution for quality process control. Results: The quality and process control models for herbal medicinal products were proposed and the transitivity and traceability system from raw materials to the finished products was constructed to improve the herbal quality from the entire supply and production chain. Conclusion: The transitivity and traceability system has been established based on quality markers, especially on how to control the production process under Good Engineering Practices, as well as to implement the risk management for quality and process control in herbal medicine production.
Quality assessment of traditional Chinese medicine based on data fusion combined with machine learning: A review

Rong Ding,Lianhui Yu,Chenghui Wang,Shihong Zhong,Rui Gu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/10408347.2023.2189477

2023-03-28

Critical Reviews in Analytical Chemistry

Abstract:The authenticity and quality of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) directly impact clinical efficacy and safety. Quality assessment of traditional Chinese medicine (QATCM) is a global concern due to increased demand and shortage of resources. Recently, modern analytical technologies have been extensively investigated and utilized to analyze the chemical composition of TCM. However, a single analytical technique has some limitations, and judging the quality of TCM only from the characteristics of the components is not enough to reflect the overall view of TCM. Thus, the development of multi-source information fusion technology and machine learning (ML) has further improved QATCM. Data information from different analytical instruments can better understand the connection between herbal samples from multiple aspects. This review focuses on the use of data fusion (DF) and ML in QATCM, including chromatography, spectroscopy, and other electronic sensors. The common data structures and DF strategies are introduced, followed by ML methods, including fast-growing deep learning. Finally, DF strategies combined with ML methods are discussed and illustrated for research on applications such as source identification, species identification, and content prediction in TCM. This review demonstrates the validity and accuracy of QATCM-based DF and ML strategies and provides a reference for developing and applying QATCM methods.

chemistry, analytical
A Strategy for Selecting “Q-Markers” of Chinese Medical Preparation via Components Transfer Process Analysis with Application to the Quality Control of Shengmai Injection

Chunxia Zhao,Huan Liu,Peiqi Miao,Houen Wang,Heshui Yu,Chunhua Wang,Zheng Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/molecules24091811

IF: 4.6

2019-05-10

Molecules

Abstract:Chinese medical preparation has complicated chemical constituents. Consequently, the proper quality control methods for these Chinese medical preparations have been great challenges to the traditional Chinese medicine modernization and internationalization. What components should be chosen for quality control is a big challenge in the development of traditional Chinese medicine. A new concept of “Quality Marker” was proposed by Liu et al. to solve this problem and established a new research paradigm for traditional Chinese medicine quality study. Several strategies were proposed by the researchers in traditional Chinese medicine, here, we used Shengmai injection as an example to discuss a strategy for selecting “Quality Markers” of Chinese medical preparation by the components transfer process analysis in the Shengmai injection manufacturing process. Firstly, a total of 87 compounds were identified or partially characterized in shengmai injection. Secondly, referenced to the quality control method in China pharmacopeia and considered the biomarkers in the original medicines and representative components in the manufacturing process, four ginsenosides in Panax ginseng (Hongshen), two compounds in Schisandra chinensis (Wuweizi), and a sugar from Ophiopogon japonicas (Maidong) were quantified. As a result, these seven representative compounds exhibited an acceptable transitivity throughout the Shengmai injection manufacturing process. Finally, combined with the active ingredients, components transfer process analysis, and comprehensive evaluation by “Spider-web” analysis, six compounds were selected as the quality markers for the quality control of Shengmai injection. Through this strategy of optimization for quality markers of Shengmai injection, we found that these six compounds could represent the main bioactive substances and be easily detected in the whole process of production. Furthermore, the quality control method was developed for quality assessment and control of these six quality markers in the Shengmai injection. The total content range of the selected quality markers in the 10 batches of the Shengmai injection is 13.844-22.557 mg/mL.

chemistry, multidisciplinary,biochemistry & molecular biology
The Qualitative and Quantitative Assessment of Tea Quality Based on E-nose, E-tongue and E-eye Combined with Chemometrics.

Min Xu,Jun Wang,Luyi Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodchem.2019.03.080

IF: 8.8

2019-01-01

Food Chemistry

Abstract:Electronic nose (E-nose), electronic tongue (E-tongue) and electronic eye (E-eye) combined with chemometrics methods were applied for qualitative identification and quantitative prediction of tea quality. Main chemical components, such as amino acids, catechins, polyphenols and caffeine were measured by traditional methods. Feature-level fusion strategy for the integration of the signals was introduced to integrate the E-nose, E-tongue and E-eye signals, aiming at improving the performances of identification and prediction models. Perfect results with an accuracy of 100% were obtained for qualitative identification of tea quality grades, based on fusion signals by support vector machine and random forest. Quantitative models were established for predicting the contents of the chemical components based on independent electronic signals and fusion signals by partial least squares regression, support vector machine and random forest. Random forest based on the fusion signals achieved the best performance in predicting the concentration of those chemical components.
[Discovery and application of traditional Chinese medicine efficacy markers based on systematic traditional Chinese medicine]

Meng-Qi Huo,Sha Peng,Yue Ren,Zhan Shu,Yan-Ling Zhang,Yan-Jiang Qiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.19540/j.cnki.cjcmm.20200210.402

Abstract:The quality marker(Q-marker) of traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) is a new concept of TCM quality control proposed in recent years. It is a hot issue in the research of modern Chinese medicine. The TCM efficacy is a high-level summary of the TCM therapeutic effect under the guidance of TCM theory. On this basis, it is of considerable significance to explore the TCM efficacy marker for the TCM modernization. However, the traditional research strategy based on the single herb and decoction piece in macro TCM level, or the drug research strategy based on the biological effect of the targets, is quite different from the characteristics of multiple components of TCM, as well as the weak and low-selective effect of Chinese medicine ingredients on targets. Therefore, how to select representative ingredients to characterize the TCM overall efficacy is a problematic point in establishing TCM efficacy markers. In this paper, the concept and method of Q-marker were introduced into the study of Chinese medicine efficacy. The research method for systematic TCM was used to systematically discuss the connotation of TCM efficacy markers, the principles of discovery and determination, common research ideas and techniques by taking the representative research results as an example. This study provides new ideas for the research and discovery of TCM efficacy markers.
The application of machine learning and artificial intelligence technology in the production quality management of traditional Chinese medicine decoction pieces

Jie Gao,Jin Li,Peiling Duan,Gao, Jie

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12008-023-01448-9

2023-08-04

International Journal on Interactive Design and Manufacturing

Abstract:The new generation of information technology represented by Big data has developed rapidly. The gradual integration of related technologies with modern manufacturing, service industry, and industrial production has achieved technological innovation and improved production service efficiency. Applying intelligent Big data to the production of traditional Chinese medicine has become an important technical means to improve the market competitiveness of the traditional Chinese medicine industry. The healthy China strategy is constantly advancing, the application of traditional Chinese medicine decoction pieces is gradually widespread. However, there are many factors affecting the quality of decoction pieces of traditional Chinese medicine. The decoction pieces quality of traditional Chinese medicine mainly depends on the experience of relevant personnel, and the identification effect is limited. How to ensure the quality of decoction pieces directly affects the establishment of the value system of traditional Chinese medicine. Under the background of developing Big-data and artificial intelligence, aiming at the current problem of quality variation in the production process of Chinese herbal medicines, the color, spots, texture, and geometric features of traditional Chinese medicine slices images are extracted. Then, based on machine learning methods, a corresponding quality evaluation model for traditional Chinese medicine slices is constructed. The quality of the acquired feature images is classified adopting a support vector machine. This shows that the accuracy of the quality identification method based on computer vision technique and support vector machine for traditional Chinese medicine decoction pieces proposed by the study reaches 95.59%, which can effectively distinguish the quality of Chinese herbal pieces and provide support for developing Chinese medicine.
A three-dimensional integration strategy for Q-markers identification: Taken Euphorbia Pekinensis Radix as an example

Xiao-Tao Zeng,Yan-Yan Chen,Shi-Jun Yue,Ding-Qiao Xu,Rui-Jia Fu,Jie-Yang,Yu-Ping Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpba.2022.115170

IF: 3.571

2022-11-23

Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis

Abstract:Euphorbia Pekinensis Radix (EPR) is an important antitumor medicinal resource. However, quality control of EPR has not been well established due to the lack of quality markers (Q-markers) research. In this study, a three-dimensional integration strategy was developed to systematically characterize Q-markers and this method was successfully applied to identify Q-markers of EPR. Firstly, three core quality attributes-effectiveness, testability and specificity-were considered as three dimensions, and the weights of each dimension were calculated by analytical hierarch process. Then, the values of each dimension were evaluated by multi-indicators. For EPR with antitumor activity, cytotoxic assay and network pharmacology, UPLC analysis and literature search, compound belonging search were employed to calculate the values of effectiveness, testability and specificity, respectively. Finally, the weights and values were multiplied as the scores of each component on that dimension, and the total scores of the three dimensions were further integrated based on the radar plot and expressed as regression area, by which Q-markers were quantified and visualized. Five components were identified as Q-markers of EPR due to their high-ranked antitumor capacity, ease of measurement and excellent specificity, which laid an important foundation for the quality control improvement of EPR. Furthermore, the integrated strategy summarized here is helpful for the quantitative identification of Q-markers and promote the quality standard of traditional Chinese medicine.

pharmacology & pharmacy,chemistry, analytical
A strategy takes "Yiqing" tablets as an example to carry out simpler multi-component quantification and use fingerprint technology for comprehensive quality consistency evaluation

Xiaoling Liu,Ting Yang,Lu Chen,Lili Lan,Guoxiang Sun,Ping Guo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpba.2023.115809

2024-01-20

Abstract:The comprehensive evaluation of the quality of traditional Chinese medicines (TCM) is an important issue for the continuous progress and exploration of TCM. In this study, a "Yiqing" tablet (YQT) was taken as an example, and the sample quality was comprehensively investigated by multi-component quantification, multi-dimensional fingerprint construction, and antioxidant activity analysis. Based on high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) and fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) fingerprint, accurate and fast multi-component quantification is achieved by reliable Multi-markers assay by mono-linear method (MAML) method and verified partial least squares regression (PLSR) model. The basic HPLC fingerprint and the special FTIR quantitative fingerprint were evaluated by SQFM, and the rich fingerprint qualitative and quantitative information of the sample was obtained. The characteristic parameter (blocking rate (BR)) characterizing antioxidant activity in the electrochemical (EC) fingerprint was excavated for the first time, and the fingerprint-efficacy analysis results with HPLC and FTIR were obtained through bivariate correlation analysis (BCA). The results showed that 25 components in the HPLC fingerprint and had antioxidant activity, and most bands of FTIR showed antioxidant activity. Finally, by combining the evaluation results of HPLC and FTIR fingerprint using the mean method, all samples were classified as first level, except for S1, demonstrating the consistency of sample quality. Based on the comprehensive quality evaluation system combining vertical and horizontal combination, this study provides a new idea for achieving comprehensive quality evaluation of TCM.
An integrated approach to uncover quality markers of Traditional Chinese medicine underlying chemical profiling, network target selection and metabolomics approach: Guan-Xin-Jing capsule as a model

Guanhua Zhang,Qi Wang,Xin Liu,Xu Wang,Wenyu Xie,Kun Liu,Wujun Jiang,Chenglin Mu,Huanyang Qi,Qiao Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jpba.2020.113413

IF: 3.571

2020-10-01

Journal of Pharmaceutical and Biomedical Analysis

Abstract:<p>The "multi-component and multi-target" property of traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) makes the quality control more difficult, which remains a key concern hindering the space of progress in its modernization and globalization. This study aims to provide a new strategy to discover quality markers related to the efficacy and stability of TCM based on the bioactive markers finding and differential markers finding, Guan-Xin-Jing capsule (GXJC) was used as a model. Firstly, the UHPLC-QTOF-MS/MS was performed to identify the chemical profiling of GXJC and 148 compounds were unequivocally or tentatively identified. Subsequently, the compounds with relatively low intensity, low oral bioavailability and unsuited drug likeness were removed. In addition, a network based approach by integrating candidate compound genes and disease genes was applied to further filter out the potential active compounds against coronary heart disease (CHD) and finally 7 compounds were identified as the potential bioactive markers. Moreover, to ensure the batch-to-batch consistency of GXJC, an untargeted UHPLC-QTOF-MS/MS based metabolomics approach and multivariate statistical analysis was performed and 5 compounds were identified as the potential differential markers to illustrate the discrepancy among 27 batches of GXJC. Using these strategies above, a total of 11 chemical compounds in GXJC were screened out as quality markers(Q-markers). The information generated with our strategy should be more helpful to guide the selection of the Q-markers and lay the foundation for quality control of TCM.</p>

pharmacology & pharmacy,chemistry, analytical
Quantitative ternary network-oriented discovery of Q-markers from traditional Chinese medicine prescriptions: Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Tang as a case study

Liufang Hu,Guotao Chen,Jiali Chen,Zhenyu Zou,Yuan Qiu,Jing Du,Xupeng Tong,Jiaxu Chen,Xinsheng Yao,Pei Lin,Liangliang He,Zhihong Yao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.phymed.2024.155918

IF: 6.656

Phytomedicine

Abstract:Background: The proposal of Q-markers for traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) represents a novel avenue of research pertaining to the quality control of TCM prescriptions. However, prior exploratory studies on Q-markers with multiple properties consistently neglected the consideration of weights, hampering our ability to accurately gauge the significance of each property and potentially leading to a flawed comprehension of Q-markers. Purpose: In this study, a quantitative ternary network strategy was firstly proposed to visually discover the Q-markers from TCM prescriptions, and it has been successfully applied into the quality control study of Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Tang (BZYQT), a classical TCM prescription. Methods: Firstly, the contents of 34 components in BZYQT, along with the kinetic features of 17 candidate Q-markers in biosamples (plasma and small intestinal contents), were characterized by UPLC-QqQ-MS/MS, and their immunomodulatory activities in macrophages and splenic lymphocytes were also assessed. Next, the obtained data were integrated into three properties: testability, bioavailability, effectiveness, and their weights were calculated using the entropy weight method to further establish a ternary network for quantitatively screening Q-markers. Subsequently, the identified Q-markers of BZYQT were utilized for the holistic quality evaluation of 36 batches of the commercial BZYQT preparation, Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Pill (BZYQP) produced by three manufacturers, through similarity evaluation of the Q-marker-based fingerprint. Results: Nine compounds (hesperidin, astragaloside IV, ononin, 18β-glycyrrhizic acid, narirutin, calycosin, cimigenoside, astragaloside II, and liquiritin) showing three core properties, including testability, bioavailability, and effectiveness, were screened out as Q-markers of BZYQT based on their rankings in terms of regression area of the ternary network. Employing Q-markers as common peaks, the similarity values of 36 batches BZYQP ranged 0.914-0.998 under HPLC-UVD mode, and 0.631-1.000 under HPLC-ELSD mode, which were less than the similarity values evaluated by the conventional common peaks (HPLC-UVD mode: 0.946-0.990; HPLC-ELSD mode: 0.957-0.997). This observation suggests that the identified Q-markers are more representative as common peaks in chromatographic fingerprints for the holistic quality evaluation of TCM-related products from different manufacturers. Conclusion: The quantitative discovery of Q-markers from BZYQT laid an important foundation for holistic quality assessment of its related commercially available products, and our work offering a new strategy for ensuring the consistency and efficacy of TCM prescriptions.
Recent Analytical Approaches in Quality Control of Traditional Chinese Medicines--a Review.

Yong Jiang,Bruno David,Pengfei Tu,Yves Barbin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aca.2009.10.024

IF: 6.911

2009-01-01

Analytica Chimica Acta

Abstract:Traditional Chinese medicines (TCMs) are gaining more and more attention all over the world, due to their specific theory and long historical clinical practice. But the uncontrollable quality is a bottleneck for its modernization and globalization. This paper reviewed the recent analytical methods in the quality control of TCMs, including screening strategies of bioactive markers from TCMs through biochromatographic methods, the traditional chromatographic methods, DNA methods, as well as the spectroscopic methods, including FT-IR, NIR and NMR. The comprehensive methods, such as fingerprint and multi-component quantification are emphasized; hyphenated techniques, like HPLC-MS, GC-MS, CE-MS, LC-NMR, chemometric methods, and combination of chemical and biological methods, such as biofingerprint, metabolic fingerprint are now more and more widely used in TCMs. In a few word, the analysis and quality control of TCMs are moving towards an integrative and comprehensive direction, in order to better address the inherent holistic nature of TCMs.

From quality markers to data mining and intelligence assessment: A smart quality-evaluation strategy for traditional Chinese medicine based on quality markers

From biological potency absorbed components to artificial intelligence mining: A review of analytical strategies for the discovery and validation of quality marker in traditional Chinese medicine in the past decade

Multimodal integrated strategy for the discovery and identification of quality markers in traditional Chinese medicine

Discriminant Analysis of "Q-Markers" of Traditional Chinese Medical Injections——Taking Dan Hong Injection as a Model

A quality-comprehensive-evaluation-index-based model for evaluating traditional Chinese medicine quality

A Novel Fingerprint Method for Quality Evaluation of Chinese Medicinal Plants Based on Analytical Data Visualization

Research progress on quality markers of traditional Chinese medicine

Approaches to establish Q-markers for the quality standards of traditional Chinese medicines

Data Quality in Traditional Chinese Medicine

A New Concept on Quality Marker for Quality Assessment and Process Control of Chinese Medicines

Quality transitivity and traceability system of herbal medicine products based on quality markers

Quality assessment of traditional Chinese medicine based on data fusion combined with machine learning: A review

A Strategy for Selecting “Q-Markers” of Chinese Medical Preparation via Components Transfer Process Analysis with Application to the Quality Control of Shengmai Injection

The Qualitative and Quantitative Assessment of Tea Quality Based on E-nose, E-tongue and E-eye Combined with Chemometrics.

[Discovery and application of traditional Chinese medicine efficacy markers based on systematic traditional Chinese medicine]

The application of machine learning and artificial intelligence technology in the production quality management of traditional Chinese medicine decoction pieces

A three-dimensional integration strategy for Q-markers identification: Taken Euphorbia Pekinensis Radix as an example

A strategy takes "Yiqing" tablets as an example to carry out simpler multi-component quantification and use fingerprint technology for comprehensive quality consistency evaluation

An integrated approach to uncover quality markers of Traditional Chinese medicine underlying chemical profiling, network target selection and metabolomics approach: Guan-Xin-Jing capsule as a model

Quantitative ternary network-oriented discovery of Q-markers from traditional Chinese medicine prescriptions: Bu-Zhong-Yi-Qi-Tang as a case study

Recent Analytical Approaches in Quality Control of Traditional Chinese Medicines--a Review.