Derivation of Reliable Empirical Models Describing Lead Transfer from Metal-Polluted Soils to Radish (raphanus Sativa L.): Determining Factors and Soil Criteria.

Sha Zhang,Jing Song,Yinwen Cheng,Peter Christie,Jian Long,Lingfei Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2017.08.306
IF: 9.8
2017-01-01
The Science of The Total Environment
Abstract:Reliable models describing Pb transfer from soils to food crops are useful in the improvement of soil protection guidelines. This study provides mechanistic insights from in-situ soil solution measurement on the Pb uptake in the root tissues (RF) of radish, grown in 25 representative Pb-contaminated agricultural soils. Lead speciation and regression analysis indicate that >88.6% of the variation in RF Pb is attributable to free Pb2+ activity (aPb(2+)) in the soil solution, which is predominantly controlled by pH and DOC. Higher DOC would increase the total dissolved Pb (C-Sol-Pb) in the soil solution but reduce the bioavailability of Pb to radish. C-Sol-Pb performs poorly in predicting RF Pb unless pH and DOC are included. However, 0.01M CaCl2 extractable Pb (C-CC-Pb) alone can satisfactorily predict RF Pb, attributable to the fact that C-CC-Pb is consistent with a Pb2+. C-CC-Pb can be predicted using C-Sol-Pb and pH. Total soil Pb (C-T-Pb), or 0.43MHNO(3) extractable Pb (C-NA-Pb) has a strong, non-linear correlation with C-Sol-Pb or C-CC-Pb and it is therefore not surprising that C-T-Pb or C-NA-Pb, together with pH and CEC, can also satisfactorily predict RF Pb. Derived models are effective in identification of soils where RF Pb exceeds the food quality standard (FQS). Soil Pb criteria based on C-T-Pb, C-NA-Pb and C-CC-Pb are derived by inverse use of empirical models. The derived Pb criterion (target value) based on C-CC-Pb is 0.02 mg kg(-1) and the stricter criterion (safe value) is 0.01 mg kg(-1), which allows a 5% probability for RF Pb to exceed FQS. Safe values based on CT-Pb and C-NA-Pb ranged from 26 to 1036 mg kg(-1) and 9 to 745 mg kg(-1), respectively. (C) 2017 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?