Abstract:An important problem in single-player video game design is how to sequence game elements within a level (or “chunk”) of the game. Each element has two critical features: a reward (e.g., earning an item or being able to watch a cinematic) and a degree of difficulty (e.g., how much energy or focus is needed to interact with the game element). The latter property is a distinctive feature in video games. Unlike passive services (like a trip to the spa) or passive entertainment (like watching sports or movies), video games often require concerted effort to consume. We study how to sequence game elements to maximize overall experienced utility subject to the dynamics of adaptation to rewards and difficulty and memory decay. We find that the optimal design depends on the relationship between rewards and difficulty, leading to qualitatively different designs. For example, when the proportion of reward-to-difficulty is high, the optimal design mimics that of more passive experiences. By contrast, the optimal design of games with low reward-to-difficulty ratios resembles work-out routines with “warm-ups” and “cool-downs.” Intermediate cases may follow the classical “mini-boss, end-boss” design where difficulty has two peaks. Numerical results reveal optimal designs with “waves” of reward and difficulty with multiple peaks. Level designs with multiple peaks of difficulty are ubiquitous in video games. In summary, this paper provides practical guidance to game designers on how to match the design of single-player games to the relationship between reward and difficulty inherent in their game’s mechanics. Our model also has implications for other interactive services that share similarities with games, such as summer camps for children. This paper was accepted by Jeanette Song, operations management. Funding: This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China [Project 72201210] and Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada [Grant RGPIN-2020-06488]. Supplemental Material: The data files and online appendices are available at https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2022.4665 .

Close Games Versus Blowouts: Optimal Challenge Reinforces One's Intrinsic Motivation to Win.

Inverted U-Shaped Curvilinear Relationship Between Challenge and One's Intrinsic Motivation: Evidence from Event-Related Potentials.

Taking Others as a Mirror: Contingent Social Comparison Promotes Task Engagement.

When feeling positive is being “in the zone”: How challenge optimality causes changes in positive affect and flow

Desire for Success Awakens: Proof of Competence Restoration in a Non-competitive Environment

Attentional Bias in Competitive Situations: Winner Does Not Take All

Intrinsic motivation in competition: The intervening role of four individual differences following objective competence information

Influence of Competition-Outcome Feedback in Video Games on Players’ Flow Experience

Make or break: The influence of expected challenges and rewards on the motivation and experience associated with cognitive effort exertion

A Surprising Source of Self-Motivation: Prior Competence Frustration Strengthens One's Motivation to Win in Another Competence-Supportive Activity.

Digital Games and Beyond: What Happens when Players Compete?

Brain Activity in Advantageous and Disadvantageous Situations: Implications for Reward/punishment Sensitivity in Different Situations.

Having to versus wanting to play: Background and consequences of harmonious versus obsessive engagement in video games

Set Players to Stun: Inducing Basic Psychological Need Frustration in a Casual Video Game

More Challenging or More Achievable? the Impacts of Difficulty and Dominant Goal Orientation in Leaderboards Within Educational Gamification

A Gamified Experiential Learning Intervention for Engaging Students Through Satisfying Needs

Science to practice: Does gamification enhance intrinsic motivation?

Things Become Appealing When I Win: Neural Evidence of the Influence of Competition Outcomes on Brand Preference

Optimal Sequencing in Single-Player Games

Wean Your Child off Video Games: Using External Rewards to Undermine Intrinsic Motivation to Play Interesting Video Games

Decision-making after Continuous Wins or Losses in a Randomized Guessing Task: Implications for How the Prior Selection Results Affect Subsequent Decision-Making