Rations and Nutritional Needs
E. Bransby,H. E. Magee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1136/BMJ.1.4502.525
1947-04-19
British Medical Journal
Abstract:Before the introduction of bread rationing the amounts of nutrients present in rationed foods* gave an inadequate picture of the sufficiency of the diet available to individuals or groups because of the large contribution made by bread to the nutritive value. The main contribution of bread is in respect of calories, protein, and the B vitamins, and its inclusion among the rationed foods was a step of fundamental importance. The rationing of bread reduced considerably the flexibility of the national diet; for it was formerly the main elastic reserve whereby those with large appetites could readily satisfy their needs. With the introduction of bread rationing it became inevitable to provide an increased supply for those with large energy requirements. Energy needs depend not only on obvious factors, such as body size and intensity of work, which are physiologically predictable, but also on unpredictables inherent in the personality or constitution of the individual. Because of the multiplicity of factors, particularly the unpredictables, that determine the needs for energy, it is beyond the wit of man to devise a workable scale of energy allowances strictly applicable to each individual in a mixed community. The rationing scheme is necessarily based on the average requirements of sections of the population. These averages embrace a wide range of variations which cannot be fully and accurately provided for in a national scheme. It is therefore inevitable that the rations should vary in accordance with individual requirements from relative excess on the one hand to relative deficiency on the other. The puLrpose of this paper is to compare the amounts of nutrients, particularly calories, in the rations with the theoretical needs of differents sections of the population, to ascertain the gaps between these two, and to examine the means whereby the gaps can be bridged. One of the fundamental principles in the scheme of rationing is that it should provide the bulk of the essential nutrients required by mothers, children, and invalids (priority classes). Many of the foods of special value for these classes, such as milk and eggs, are also good sources of energy. Consequently, their rations yield a larger proportion of their energy needs than is the case with other classes, so that the gap between the energy content of the rations and theoretical needs is smaller. Notwithstanding the rationing of bread there still exists considerable flexibility in the rationing system, and this derives from one or more of the following: (a) unrationed foods; (b) canteen, school, or similar extra meals; (c) the use of i"points" to the best advantage, including exchange of points into bread units (B.U.s) ; and (d) diversion of rations from family members with small needs to others with greater needs (the family pool). (a) Unrationed Foods.-The chief of these is potatoes, but they are relatively bulky; 16 oz. (454 g.), which is probably as much as the ordinary consumer ever eats, yields only 260 calories. Fruit and vegetables are relatively poor sources of energy, 8 oz. (227 g.), which is a fairly generous daily amount, yields on the average only about 50 calories. There remain fish, offal, sausages, and a few other foods of less importance, the procurement of which depends upon a complexity of factors; together they would probably yield not more than about 150 calories a day in normal circumstances. (b) Canteen and Other Meals.-Those who have access to public eating-places could get almost any proportion of their requirements from this source, but permanent residents in hotels rrmust surrender their ration books. School meals are planned to provide a maximum of 1,000 calories daily. Canteen meals and snacks could provide up to 1,000 calories or more daily. (c) Exchange of Points to B.U.s.-The food value obtainable from a given number of points is variable, but, generally speaking, better nutritional value can be obtained from spending points on simple things, such as dried pulses and sardines, than on luxury foods, such as expensive canned fruits and biscuits. Exchange of all points to B.U.s would produce an average gain of some 350 calories, or about 50 per exchanged point a day. (d) The Family Pool.-As pointed out below, the rations of young children provide in themselves more than enough calories for their needs. In addition, the energy needs of women and of old men are about 80%, or less, of those of the ordinary male, but the rations for all these are identical. It therefore follows that a family comprising one or more such people would have some spare rations to pass on to those with bigger appetites. For instance, about 100 calories a day would be provided by one ration of bacon and cheese, plus 1 oz. (28 g.) of fat weekly. These spare rations would, in addition, provide a " lubricant " for the greater consumption of unrationed foods such as potatoes.