Abstract:Analysis of combined deployments of GPS loggers with cameras or temperature–depth recorders reveals that despite experiencing intraspecific competition for food, northern gannets engage in dynamic, context‐dependent social associations while foraging. Foraging aggregations far from the colony may be beneficial as a source of local enhancement, which may impact foraging profitability and increase access to echelon groups to facilitate colony return. Our results therefore illustrate how competition may, paradoxically, facilitate some aspects of group foraging in colonial animals. Coloniality is strongly shaped by aspects of social foraging behaviour. For example, colonies may be important sources of information, while food competition may increase foraging efforts and limit colony size. Understanding foraging ecology considering these apparent trade‐offs is required to develop a better understanding of colonial living. We combined animal‐borne GPS, cameras and dive recorders to study social foraging in breeding adult northern gannets Morus bassanus—a wide‐ranging colonial seabird. We first tested for indirect evidence of prey depletion around the colony by estimating dive location, depth and duration. Next, we tested for sociality during different behaviours (commuting, foraging and resting) and distance from the colony. Finally, we quantified flocks of inbound and outbound birds to compare social foraging between outbound and inbound legs of the commute. Dive probability and depth (n = 46 individuals; n = 1590 dives) increased with distance from the colony, creating dive clusters at ~100 and 180 km consistent with conspecific prey depletion. Camera stills (n = 8 individuals; n = 7495 images) show gannets are highly social, but this varied among behaviours. Sociality was highest during foraging and commuting; especially inbound and social foraging was more likely far from the colony. Gannets were equally likely to be solitary or social when leaving the colony but returning birds were more likely in larger flocks. In summary, despite experiencing intraspecific competition for food, gannets engage in dynamic, context‐dependent social foraging associations. Conspecifics aggregated far from the colony possibly because of a prey depletion halo closer to home, but this provided potential benefits via local enhancement and by returning to the colony in flocks. Our results therefore illustrate how competition may, paradoxically, facilitate some aspects of group foraging in colonial animals.

Integrating behavior and physiology supports Storer-Ashmole's halo in a central place forager

Central place foragers, prey depletion halos, and how behavioral niche partitioning promotes consumer coexistence

Competition and Facilitation Influence Central Place Foraging Ecology in a Colonial Marine Predator

Foraging range scales with colony size in high-latitude seabirds

Hierarchical foraging strategies of migratory short-tailed shearwaters during the non-breeding stage

Influence of sea ice concentration, sex and chick age on foraging flexibility and success in an Arctic seabird

Bringing Home the Trash: Do Colony-Based Differences in Foraging Distribution Lead to Increased Plastic Ingestion in Laysan Albatrosses?

Spatial consistency affects foraging effort in a benthic diving seabird, the Black‐faced Cormorant

From route to dive: multi-scale habitat selection in a foraging tropical seabird

Foraging plasticity in Chilean flamingos: influence of water depth, food abundance and intra-flock distances

Age, sex, and temperature shape off-territory feeder use in black-capped chickadees

Behavioural flexibility in an Arctic seabird using two distinct marine habitats to survive the energetic constraints of winter

Changes in Behaviour and Proxies of Physiology Suggest Individual Variation in the Building of Migratory Phenotypes in Preparation for Long-Distance Flights

Multidimensional niche differentiation of chick-rearing sympatric auks in the Gulf of St. Lawrence

Breeding stage and tissue isotopic consistency suggests colony-level flexibility in niche breadth of an Arctic marine bird

Comparable foraging effort and habitat use between two geographically proximate tropical seabird colonies

Northern Gannet foraging trip length increases with colony size and decreases with latitude

Horizontal prey distribution determines the foraging performance of short‐ and long‐billed waders in virtual resource landscapes

GPS tracking analyses reveal finely-tuned shorebird space use and movement patterns throughout the non-breeding season in high-latitude austral intertidal areas

Intrinsic and extrinsic factors modulating vigilance and foraging in two gregarious foragers

Energetic trade-offs in migration decision-making, reproductive effort and subsequent parental care in a long-distance migratory bird