Trans-Carbamoylation Enabled Intrinsic Plasticity for Thermoset Shape Memory Polyurethane
Zizheng Fang,Weike Zou,Qian Zhao,Tao Xie
2016-01-01
Abstract:Thermoset polymers are known for their superior thermomechanical performances, but their chemical crosslinking nature typically leads to the intractability. This is reflected in the stark contrast between thermoset and thermoplastic shape memory polymers with the former exhibiting robust shape memory performances but its inability to redefine the permanent shape. Contrary to current knowledge, we reveal here that a classical thermoset shape memory polyurethane readily exhibits an ability in permanent reshaping (plasticity) via trans-carbamoylation enabled network topological rearrangement. By employing a Jianzhi technique (also known as kirigami), we demonstrate unexpected shape shifting versatility for such an otherwise classical material. Since the essential carbamate bond in polyurethanes is one of the most common polymer building units, we anticipate that our finding will lead to enormous benefits in the future beyond shape shifting. Shape memory polymer (SMP) is a class of smart material capable of fixing temporary programmed shapes and recovering to its permanent shape upon external stimulation. Although polymer shape memory behavior has been known for over half a century, intense interests have only been stimulated in the last decade due to the emergence of a variety of high value added engineering applications including biomedical devices, deployable aerospace structures, and functionally tunable devices. At the fundamental level of material behaviors, the recent discovery of multi-shape memory and reversible shape memory effects has further fueled the explosive growth. Regardless of the complexity of the shape memory behaviors, enabling such properties generally requires the combination of cross-linking and reversible thermal transition. Chemical crosslinking leads to thermoset SMP with robust shape memory behaviors but comes at a cost of losing reprocessability. In contrast, physical crosslinked SMPs can be reprocessed, but often suffer from compromised shape fixity and recovery. A prime example reflecting such a dilemma is shape memory polyurethanes (SMPU). Thermoplastic SMPU represents one of the earliest studied SMPs with their hard and soft domains serving as the physical crosslinkers and thermo-reversible shape memory transition, respectively. Despite its inferior performance relative to its thermoset counterpart, its reprocessability has sustained the interest on this class of materials for many years. In contrast, thermoset polyurethane chemistry has also been widely used in SMP design due to the versatility of the chemistry and the robustness of the resulting materials. However, it is generally understood that thermoset polyurethane cannot be reprocessed, or in the context of shape memory, the permanent shape of classical thermoset SMPU cannot be altered. In the general area of polymer materials beyond SMP, resolving the dilemma between thermosets and thermoplastics has historically attracted significant attention. The recently emerged concept of vitrimers is particularly noteworthy. The concept relies on triggering transesterification reactions in a thermoset to allow network topological rearrangement for reprocessing. However, network reformulation to introduce a sufficient amount of ester linkages in the network is needed. Nevetheless, this mechanism has since been extended to various systems based on other exchangeable reactions including siloxane equilibrium, olefin metathesis, and boronic ester exhange. Whereas the vitrimer concept emphasizes more on thermally activated bond exchange, photo-activation via addition-fragmentation chain transfer reaction or disulfide bond exchange also permits network rearrangement for permanent thermoset reshaping. Overall, thermoset reprocessing or reshaping via exchangeable bonds holds great promise but it generally requires delicate network reformulation, which often prohibits their practical potential. Polyurethane thermosets represent a class of materials with important industrial applications. Intriguingly, their essential carbamate bonds are known to be exchangeable yet the reprocessibility of thermoset polyurethanes has been found to be rather “sluggish”. Presumably, this is the very reason why the reversible nature of carbamate bonds has been largely neglected despite their importance as the common polymer building units and the ever-increasing interest on reversible covalent bonds. Nevertheless, it is generally recognized that unless the primary structures of thermoset polyurethanes are altered, their reprocessing via carbamate-only bond exchange is non-practical. This resonates well with the common belief that the permanent shape of thermoset shape memory polyurethanes (SMPU) cannot be redefined. Contrary to this, we illustrate below that the ability to repetitively reset the permanent shape is an intrinsic attribute for classical thermoset SMPU. We start with thermoset SMPU with carbamate bonds as the only potentially active structural moieties in the networks, as synthesized by reacting (polyethylene glycol)diol (PEG) and glycerine (GLY) with hexamethylene diisocyanate (HDI) (Figure 1). A common catalyst dibutyltin dilaurate (DBTDL) is also present (0.5, 1, and 2 wt%) in the formulation. All three samples show high gel contents (91.6%, 93.7%, and 94.0%, respectively), confirming their thermoset nature. Differential scanning calorimetry analysis (DSC) and dynamic mechanical analysis (DMA) (Figures S1a and S1b, 1 wt% catalyst unless otherwise noted) show that the network possesses a melting transition around 41 oC from the PEG chain segments. Importantly, no other peak can be identified in the DSC curve and a perfect rubbery plateau was observed in the DMA curve. These are features fully expected with the simplest and rather classical thermoset SMPU. The surprise started when three samples with various catalyst contents were subjected to iso-strain stress relaxation [*] N. Zheng, Z.Z. Fang, W.K. Zou, Prof. Q Zhao, Prof. T. Xie State Key Laboratory of Chemical Engineering, College of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Zhejiang University, 38 Zheda Road, Hangzhou, 310027, P. R. China E-mail: qianzhao@zju.edu.cn, taoxie@zju.edu.cn Supporting information including experimental section for this article is given via a link at the end of the document.