Computational design of cooperatively acting molecular catalyst systems: carbene based tungsten- or molybdenum-catalysts with rhodium- or iridium-complexes for the ionic hydrogenation of N 2 to NH 3

Totan Mondal,Walter Leitner,Markus Hölscher
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1039/d4dt00563e
IF: 4
2024-04-20
Dalton Transactions
Abstract:This density functional theory (DFT) study explores the efficacy of cooperative catalytic systems in enabling the ionic hydrogenation of N 2 with H 2 , leading to NH 3 formation. A set of N-heterocyclic carbene-based pincer tungsten/molybdenum metal complexes of the form [(PCP)M 1 (H) 2 ] (M 1 = W/Mo) were chosen to bind N 2 at the respective metal centres. Simultaneously, cationic rhodium/iridium complexes of type [Cp*M 2 {2-(2-pyridyl)phenyl}(CH 3 CN)] + (Cp* = C 5 (CH 3 ) 5 and M 2 = Rh/Ir), are employed as cooperative coordination partners for heterolytic H 2 splitting. The stepwise transfer of protons and hydrides to the bound N 2 and intermediate N x H y units results in the formation of NH 3 . Interestingly, the calculated results reveal an encouraging low range of energy spans ranging from ∼30 to 42 kcal mol −1 depending on different combinations of ligands and metal complexes. The optimal combination of pincer ligand and metal center allowed for an energy span of unprecedented 29.7 kcal mol −1 demonstrating significant potential for molecular catalysts for the N 2 /H 2 reaction system. While exploring obvious potential off-cycle reactions leading to catalyst deactivation, the computed results indicate that no increase in energy span would need to be expected.
chemistry, inorganic & nuclear
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily focuses on addressing the catalytic issues in the conversion of nitrogen (N₂) to ammonia (NH₃). Specifically, it aims to achieve this goal by designing a novel cooperative molecular catalyst system. Below is a summary of the key issues the paper attempts to solve: ### Core Issues Addressed by the Paper 1. **Developing Efficient Catalysts**: Finding catalysts that can effectively promote the conversion of N₂ to NH₃, especially under mild conditions (i.e., without requiring extreme temperatures or pressures). 2. **Reducing Energy Barriers**: Lowering the energy barriers of various steps in the catalytic cycle, particularly the energy span of key steps, to improve catalytic efficiency. 3. **Designing a Cooperative Catalytic System**: Constructing a cooperative catalytic system composed of tungsten or molybdenum metal complexes with rhodium or iridium complexes, where the tungsten or molybdenum metal complexes are used for terminal coordination of N₂, and the rhodium or iridium complexes are used for heterolytic cleavage of H₂. 4. **Evaluating the Impact of Different Ligands**: Investigating the impact of different N-heterocyclic carbene-phosphine ligand frameworks on catalytic performance, including changes in electronic properties and spatial effects. 5. **Exploring the Role of Metal Centers**: Comparing the roles of different metal centers (such as molybdenum and tungsten) in the catalytic system and their impact on the energy span. 6. **Considering the Possibility of Side Reactions**: Assessing the potential side reactions (e.g., catalyst dimerization) that may affect the efficiency of the catalytic cycle and taking measures to prevent these side reactions. 7. **Optimizing the Catalyst System**: Using theoretical calculations to screen for the most effective catalyst system, including the type of metal, ligand type, and reaction conditions. In summary, this study aims to explore a molecular catalyst system that can efficiently catalyze the hydrogenation of N₂ under mild conditions through theoretical calculations. It focuses on analyzing the impact of different factors on catalytic performance, providing theoretical guidance for further experimental research.