Abstract:Although fluency theory predominates psychological research on human aesthetics, its most severe limitation may be to explain why art that challenges or even violates easy processing can nevertheless be aesthetically rewarding. We discuss long-standing notions on art's potential to offer mental growth opportunities and to tap into a basic epistemic predisposition that hint at a fluency counteracting aesthetic pleasure mechanism. Based on divergent strands of literature on empirical, evolutionary, and philosophical aesthetics, as well as research on disfluency, we presumed that challenging art requires deliberate reflexive processing at the level of "aboutness" in order to be experientially pleasing. Here, we probed such a cognitive mastering mechanism, achieved by iterative cycles of elaboration, as predicted by our model of aesthetic experiences. For the study, two kinds of portraits were applied, one associable to a high fluency and one to a high stimulation potential (according to results of an extensive rating study). In Experiment 1, we provided a repeated evaluation task, which revealed a distinctive preference effect for challenging portraits that was absent in the visual exposition conditions of a familiarity and a mere exposure task (Experiment 2). In a follow-up task (Experiment 3) this preference effect was observed with a novel and more encompassing pool of portraits, which corroborated its stability and robustness. In an explorative stimulus-transfer task (Experiment 4), we investigated the presumed underlying mechanism by testing whether the observed effect would generalize onto novel portraits of the same artist-specific styles. Results discounted an alternative interpretation of a perceptual adaptation effect and hinted at meaning-driven mental activity. Conjointly, findings for inexperienced viewers were indicative of an elaboration based mastering mechanism that selectively operated for mentally challenging portraits. Moreover, findings were in line with a dual-process view of human preference formation with art. Theoretical implications and boundary conditions are discussed.

Symmetry and Meaningfulness in the Spotlight of Expertness

The effect of art expertise on visual symmetry and asymmetry preference

Explicit and Implicit Preference for Symmetry Across Object Categories

Cognitive Basis For The Development Of Aesthetic Preference: Findings From Symmetry Preference

The quest for psychological symmetry through figural goodness, randomness, and complexity: A selective review

Beauty is in the eye of the beholder: Evidence from a common mnemonic advantage between aesthetics judgement and self-reference

Beyond Beauty: Design Symmetry and Brand Personality

The aesthetic preference for symmetry dissociates from early-emerging attention to symmetry.

Beauty in the eye of the self: novices' aesthetic art preferences, stimulation potential, and self-concepts

The roles of handedness and stimulus asymmetry in aesthetic preference

Photographs that repulse or entice: Sense-making and emotional experiencing of artistic photographs.

Aesthetic Motivation Impacts Judgments of Others’ Prosociality and Mental Life

The Influence of Art Expertise and Training on Emotion and Preference Ratings for Representational and Abstract Artworks

Symmetry as a Representation of Intuitive Geometry?

Sensory Processing of Art as a Unique Window into Cognitive Mechanisms: Evidence from Behavioral Experiments and fMRI Studies

Investigating the Relationship between Balanced Composition and Aesthetic Judgment through Computational Aesthetics and Neuroaesthetic Approaches

Aesthetic appreciation is more than seeing, and symbolicity is more than discriminating: a comment on Tylén et al. (2020)

When Challenging Art Gets Liked: Evidences for a Dual Preference Formation Process for Fluent and Non-Fluent Portraits

Limits in the Perception of Facial Symmetry—A Prospective Study

Aesthetic Evaluation of Computer Icons: Visual Pattern Differences Between Art-Trained and Lay Raters of Icons

A Farewell to Art: Aesthetics as a Topic in Psychology and Neuroscience