Fine-tuning Heuristic Methods for Combinatorial Optimization in Forest Planning

Xingji Jin,Timo Pukkala,Fengri Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10342-016-0971-x
2016-01-01
European Journal of Forest Research
Abstract:Heuristic methods are commonly used in complicated spatial forest planning problems to find the best combination of management alternatives for stands. The performance of heuristic methods depends on the parameters that guide their search processes. This study used numerical optimization to find the optimal parameter values for simulated annealing (SA), threshold accepting (TA), great deluge (GD), tabu search (TS), genetic algorithm (GA) and ant colony optimization (AC) when they are used for combinatorial optimization in forest planning. Ant colony optimization was implemented using the Max–Min Ant System, which was applied for the first time to forest planning problem. Solutions found by different heuristic methods for a non-spatial and a spatial forest planning problem were compared in a situation where the search time was restricted. The comparisons revealed that SA and TA were the best methods for fast search in both non-spatial and spatial problems. GA and AC were the least satisfactory methods, and GD and TS were between the best and the worst heuristics. The main reason for the poor performance of GA and AC was their slow search process. Differences between heuristic methods decreased when the allowed search time increased.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?