Abstract:In the fields of heuristic optimization and machine learning, experimentation is the way to assess the performance of an algorithm setup and the hardness of problems. Most algorithms in the domain are anytime algorithms, meaning that they can improve their approximation quality over time. This means that one algorithm may initially perform better than another one, but converge to worse solutions in the end. Instead of single final results, the whole runtime behavior of algorithms needs to be compared. Moreover, a researcher does not just want to know which algorithm performs best and which problem is the hardest – she/he wants to know why. In this paper, we introduce a process which can 1) automatically model the progress of algorithm setups on different problem instances based on data collected in experiments, 2) use these models to discover clusters of algorithm (or problem instance) behaviors, and 3) propose causes why a certain algorithm setup (or problem instance) belongs to a certain algorithm (or problem instance) behavior cluster. These high-level conclusions are presented in form of decision trees relating algorithm parameters (or instance features) to cluster ids. We emphasize the duality of analyzing algorithm setups and problem instances. Our process is implemented as open source software and tested in two case studies, on the Maximum Satisfiability Problem and the Traveling Salesman Problem. Besides its basic application to raw experimental data, yielding clusters and explanations of “quantitative” algorithm behavior, our process also allows for “qualitative” conclusions by feeding it with data which is normalized based on problem features or algorithm parameters. It can also be applied recursively, e.g., to further investigate the behavior of the algorithms in the cluster with the best-performing setups on the problem instances belonging to the cluster of hardest instances. Both use cases are investigated in the case studies. We conclude our article by a comprehensive analysis of the drawbacks of our method and with suggestions on how it can be improved.

Optimization Algorithm Behavior Modeling: A Study On The Traveling Salesman Problem

Modeling Optimization Algorithm Runtime Behavior and Its Applications

Benchmarking Optimization Algorithms: an Open Source Framework for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Implementation Issues in Optimization Algorithms: Do They Matter?

Automatically discovering clusters of algorithm and problem instance behaviors as well as their causes from experimental data, algorithm setups, and instance features.

A Novel Feature-Based Approach to Characterize Algorithm Performance for the Traveling Salesman Problem

Optimizing software reliability growth models through simulated annealing algorithm: parameters estimation and performance analysis

An Empirical Analysis of Approximation Algorithms for the Euclidean Traveling Salesman Problem

A Comparative Performance Analysis of Computational Intelligence Techniques to Solve the Asymmetric Travelling Salesman Problem

Selecting a Diverse Set of Benchmark Instances from a Tunable Model Problem for Black-Box Discrete Optimization Algorithms

Implementation of Mathematical Modeling Teaching Based on Intelligent Algorithm

Experimental Demonstration of A Quantum Annealing Algorithm for the Traveling Salesman Problem in A Nuclear-Magnetic-Resonance Quantum Simulator

Multimodal Optimization of Traveling Salesman Problem

How to Evaluate Machine Learning Approaches for Combinatorial Optimization: Application to the Travelling Salesman Problem

An Optimization Case Study for solving a Transport Robot Scheduling Problem on Quantum-Hybrid and Quantum-Inspired Hardware

Optimization Models for the Quadratic Traveling Salesperson Problem

Applications of Nature-Inspired Metaheuristic Algorithms for Tackling Optimization Problems Across Disciplines

An Optimization Model for Scheduling Freight Trains on a Single Rail Track

Comparative Assessment Of Light-based Intelligent Search And Optimization Algorithms

Robust Model and Algorithms for the Uncertain Traveling Salesman Problem

Principle and performance validation of search and rescue team algorithm