Abstract:Google published the first release of the Bottleneck Bandwidth and Round-trip Time (BBR) congestion control algorithm in 2016. Since then, BBR has gained a widespread attention due to its ability to operate efficiently in the presence of packet loss and in scenarios where routers are equipped with small buffers. These characteristics were not attainable with traditional loss-based congestion control algorithms such as CUBIC and Reno. BBRv2 is a recent congestion control algorithm proposed as an improvement to its predecessor, BBRv1. Preliminary work suggests that BBRv2 maintains the high throughput and the bounded queueing delay properties of BBRv1. However, the literature has been missing an evaluation of BBRv2 under different network conditions.This paper presents an experimental evaluation of BBRv2 Alpha (v2alpha-2019-07-28) on Mininet, considering alternative active queue management (AQM) algorithms, routers with different buffer sizes, variable packet loss rates and round-trip times (RTTs), and small and large numbers of TCP flows. Emulation results show that BBRv2 tolerates much higher random packet loss rates than loss-based algorithms but slightly lower than BBRv1. The results also confirm that BBRv2 has better coexistence with loss-based algorithms and lower retransmission rates than BBRv1, and that it produces low queuing delay even with large buffers. When a Tail Drop policy is used with large buffers, an unfair bandwidth allocation is observed among BBRv2 and CUBIC flows. Such unfairness can be reduced by using advanced AQM schemes such as FQ-CoDel and CAKE. Regarding fairness among BBRv2 flows, results show that using small buffers produces better fairness, without compromising high throughput and link utilization. This observation applies to BBRv1 flows as well, which suggests that rate-based model-based algorithms work better with small buffers. BBRv2 also enhances the coexistence of flows with different RTTs, mitigating the RTT unfairness problem noted in BBRv1. Lastly, the paper presents the advantages of using TCP pacing with a loss-based algorithm, when the rate is manually configured a priori. Future algorithms could set the pacing rate using explicit feedback generated by modern programmable switches.

Performance evaluation of parallel TCP, and its impact on bandwidth utilization and fairness in high-BDP networks based on test-bed

Test-Bed based Comparison of Single and Parallel TCP and the Impact Of Parallelism on Throughput and Fairness in Heterogenous Networks

CW-HSTCP: Fair TCP in High-Speed Networks

TCP CUBIC: A Transport Protocol for Improving the Performance of TCP in Long Distance High Bandwidth Cyber-Physical Systems

TCP Vegas-V: Improving the performance of TCP vegas

Evaluating Performance of Broadband NetworkBased on Indexes of TCP Messages

RTT Unfairness of HSTCP and Its Analysis

End-to-end Congestion Control for TCP-friendly Flows with Variable Data Rates

A fair bulk data transmission protocol in grid environments

Network Coded TCP (CTCP) Performance over Satellite Networks

Elastic-TCP: Flexible Congestion Control Algorithm to Adapt for High-BDP Networks

Performance analysis of high-speed TCP protocols in LTE X2 handover under realistic operational conditions

Simulation based Study of TCP Variants in Hybrid Network

Study on the Fairness of TCP Connections Competing for Resources

Transport Protocols for Large Bandwidth-Delay Product Networks - TCP Extensions and Alternative Transport Protocols

An emulation-based evaluation of TCP BBRv2 Alpha for wired broadband

On TCP performance in a heterogeneous network: a survey

TCP-FIT: an Improved TCP Algorithm for Heterogeneous Networks

Performance Analysis of Transmission Control Protocol (TCP) Variants

Evaluating TCP BBRv3 performance in wired broadband networks

Coupled CUBIC Congestion Control for MPTCP in Broadband Networks