Abstract:This paper investigates the competitive rationale for firms to invest in marketing activities aiming to enhance valuation and achieve differentiation and competitive advantage, while carrying the strategic risks of causing unintended negative consequences. We build a stylized theoretical model where firms offering similar (homogenous) products are competing by determining their marketing strategy and pricing. Each firm must choose between several marketing activities that have different potentials of enhancing consumers' product valuations while carrying some risk of lowering consumer valuation if unintended negative outcomes occur. The stochastic nature of marketing implies that (1) even when both firms invest the same amount of money aiming to enhance product valuations by the same level, there will be a variety of (posterior) vertical differentiation scenarios where the consumers could value either firm's product as better as or worse than the rival's. (2) The firms may employ marketing activities that do not even lead to gains in consumer product valuation in expectation. The duopoly model analysis indicates that associated with strategic pricing, even such stochastic marketing activities may constitute desirable strategies for two a priori symmetric firms in order to avoid a Bertrand type competition as the benefit from differentiation is found to be significant enough to offset the unintended negative outcomes. The oligopoly model analysis indicates that there is an increased incentive to take marketing risk when there is a greater level of competitive intensity in the marketplace. Preliminary experimental evidence is presented to support the main findings from theoretical model analyses. The paper thus provides important managerial implications for firms contemplating investment in seemingly risky marketing activities.

Financial Hedging and Competitive Strategy for Value-Maximizing Firms under Quantity Competition

A Strategic Asset Pricing Model for Relative Performance Concern

PN Equilibrium Strategy for Matrix Games with Fuzzy Payoffs

How Does Risk Hedging Impact Operations? Insights from a Price-Setting Newsvendor Model

Supply chain network equilibrium with strategic financial hedging using futures

Integrated Capacity and Exchange Rate Hedging in Multi-Markets under Value-at-Risk

Perfect hedging under endogenous permanent market impacts

Time to Market Strategy in a Comptitive Environment

Hedging with derivatives to increase firm value

A Game of Competition for Risk

Taking marketing strategy risks with seemingly no expected gains

Hedging under multiple risk constraints

The Determinants of Firms' Hedging Policies

Pricing strategies for competitive firms with indirect network effects

Innovative development strategy of a risk-averse firm considering product unreliability under competition

Managerial Compensation under Privately-Observed Hedging and Earnings Management

A mean field game approach to optimal investment and risk control for competitive insurers

Financial Hedging Decisions on Procurement Risk with Value-at-Risk Consideration

Efficient Markets and Contingent Claims Valuation: An Information Theoretic Approach

Intelligent option portfolio model with perspective of shadow price and risk-free profit

Hedging the portfolio of raw materials and the commodity under the mark-to-market risk