William Chu Kwan,Imogen den Otter-Moore,Ari Partanen,Karolina Piorkowska,Unni Narayanan,Adam C. Waspe,James M. Drake
Abstract:Introduction Magnetic Resonance-guided Focused Ultrasound (MRgFUS) thermal ablation is an effective noninvasive ultrasonic therapy to disrupt in vivo porcine tendon but is prone to inducing skin burns. We evaluated the safety profile of a novel hybrid protocol that minimizes thermal spread by combining long-pulse focused ultrasound followed by thermal ablation.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to address the problem of achieving non-invasive tendon release through Magnetic Resonance-guided Focused Ultrasound (MRgFUS) without causing skin burns. Specifically, the study aims to evaluate a new hybrid therapy that combines long-pulse focused ultrasound (long-pulse FUS) and thermal ablation techniques to reduce thermal diffusion and improve the safety and efficacy of the treatment.
### Background and Problem
- **Tendon Contracture**: Tendon contracture refers to the shortening of the muscle-tendon unit, leading to weakened strength and reduced range of motion around the joint, which can result in deformity, disuse, pain, and disability. In severe cases, non-surgical interventions such as physical therapy and splinting fail to achieve long-term improvements in range of motion, and surgical tendon release is the most effective treatment. However, it carries risks of recurrence, anesthesia, and surgery, and not all patients are suitable for surgery.
- **MRgFUS Technology**: High-Intensity Focused Ultrasound (HIFU) combined with Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) guidance can achieve tissue ablation without open surgery. However, traditional thermal ablation techniques are prone to causing skin burns, especially on superficial targets.
### Research Objectives
- **Primary Objective**: To evaluate the effectiveness of long-pulse focused ultrasound as a pre-ablation step to effectively disrupt the tendon by forming boiling bubble clouds within the tendon while minimizing thermal diffusion.
- **Secondary Objectives**: To assess temperature distribution, thermal dose range, skin thermal injury, changes in range of motion, and histological characteristics of the treatment, and compare these with treatments using only thermal ablation.
### Methods
- **Animal Model**: Experiments were conducted on the Achilles tendons of Yorkshire pigs weighing 15-20 kg.
- **Treatment Protocols**:
- **Traditional Thermal Ablation**: Continuous wave ultrasound ablation with energies of 600 J, 900 J, and 1200 J.
- **Hybrid Therapy**: 60 seconds of long-pulse focused ultrasound followed by 30 seconds of thermal ablation, with the same energies of 600 J, 900 J, and 1200 J.
- **Evaluation Metrics**: Including tendon rupture rate, ankle joint range of motion, maximum temperature, thermal dose area, and skin thermal injury.
### Results
- **Tendon Rupture Rate**: The tendon rupture rates for hybrid therapy and traditional thermal ablation were similar at different energy levels, but hybrid therapy produced lower maximum temperatures, smaller thermal dose areas, and less skin thermal injury, with a significantly reduced incidence of full-thickness skin burns.
- **Safety**: Hybrid therapy demonstrated better performance in reducing thermal diffusion and avoiding skin burns.
### Discussion
- **Efficacy**: Hybrid therapy's effectiveness in tendon rupture is comparable to traditional thermal ablation but with higher safety.
- **Thermal Diffusion**: Hybrid therapy reduces thermal diffusion by first applying long-pulse focused ultrasound, thereby decreasing unnecessary heating of surrounding healthy tissues.
- **Future Applications**: This study provides feasibility evidence for future clinical applications, particularly in cases requiring non-invasive treatment of tendon contracture, where hybrid therapy may be a safer option.
In summary, this paper addresses the issue of skin burns in traditional thermal ablation techniques for non-invasive tendon release by introducing hybrid therapy, thereby improving the safety and efficacy of the treatment.