Will AI Become a Threat to Higher Education Sustainability? A Study of Students' Views

Valery Okulich-Kazarin,Artem Artyukhov,Łukasz Skowron,Nadiia Artyukhova,Tomasz Wołowiec
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16114596
IF: 3.9
2024-05-29
Sustainability
Abstract:Universities started to use artificial intelligence (AI) tools to improve the quality of higher education services. However, the rapid adoption of AI tools in higher education (HE) may lead to sustainability issues. On the one hand, there are prerequisites for using AI tools to achieve Sustainable Development Goal 4 (SDG 4). On the other hand, as consumers of educational services (stakeholders), students have their own opinions about using AI in the educational process. The purpose of this study was to explore students' opinions on the use of artificial intelligence tools in higher education. The authors analyzed student responses to the question: "Do you think AI threatens higher education in the next five years?" The authors formulated this question based on the definition of "a safe learning environment", which is associated with a "safe" learning environment (SDG 4.3). The authors made use of a literature review, a bibliometric analysis of 5000 sources, a survey of 1104 students from eight universities in Eastern Europe through cloud technologies to host a special electronic questionnaire, statistical processing of questionnaires, and testing of statistical hypotheses. The authors formulated and tested two pairs of competing statistical hypotheses. Finally, the authors obtained three new scientific facts based on the respondents' answers. New scientific facts were obtained using a standard level of statistical hypothesis testing (α = 0.05). The main scientific fact is that 10.17% to 35.42% of students think that Artificial Intelligence threatens higher education. According to student opinions, AI may hurt the sustainability of higher education (SDG 4.3). The authors are confident that new scientific facts help conceptualize and promote didactic theory and practice. The study results are needed to predict, plan, and implement organizational, pedagogical, and methodological measures aimed at SDG 4.3 through a "safe" learning environment while further expanding the use of AI in higher education.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore whether the application of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in higher education poses a threat to the sustainability of higher education. Specifically, the authors investigate this issue by surveying students' perspectives. The core question of the paper is: "Do students believe that AI poses a threat to higher education within the next 5 years?" ### Research Background As universities begin to use AI tools to improve the quality of higher education services, the rapid adoption of AI in higher education may bring sustainability issues. On one hand, the use of AI tools helps achieve the United Nations Sustainable Development Goal 4 (SDG 4), particularly target 4.3, which aims to ensure that all people have access to safe, non-violent, inclusive, and effective learning environments. On the other hand, as consumers (stakeholders) of educational services, students have their own views on the use of AI in the educational process. ### Research Methods To explore students' perspectives, the authors conducted the following research: 1. **Literature Review**: Reviewed over 100 articles from the Scopus and Web of Science databases to understand the main research areas of higher education sustainability. 2. **Citation Analysis**: Conducted citation analysis on 5000 highly cited articles to identify keywords related to sustainability and higher education. 3. **Questionnaire Survey**: Conducted an electronic questionnaire survey of 1104 students from eight Eastern European universities using cloud technology. 4. **Statistical Analysis**: Performed statistical processing of the questionnaire data and tested two competing statistical hypotheses. ### Main Findings 1. **Students' Views on AI Threats**: According to students' responses, 10.17% to 35.42% of students believe that AI poses a threat to higher education within the next 5 years. This suggests that AI may have a negative impact on the sustainability of higher education (SDG 4.3). 2. **Specific Aspects of AI Threats**: - Data Security Issues: Students are concerned about the security and privacy of personal data being compromised. - Reduction of Teaching Positions: Students worry that AI tools may replace teachers, leading to unemployment among educators. 3. **Statistical Hypothesis Testing**: - Hypothesis 1: The proportion of students who believe AI threatens higher education is 0%. The verification results indicate that this hypothesis is not valid. - Hypothesis 2: The proportion of students who believe AI threatens higher education is the same as the proportion of students who believe AI will replace teachers. The verification results indicate that these two proportions are different, suggesting that students have a broader understanding of the threats posed by AI. ### Conclusion This study provides new empirical and statistical evidence that the application of AI in higher education may pose a threat to students' learning environments and the sustainability of higher education. These findings help conceptualize and develop teaching theories and practices, providing a basis for predicting, planning, and implementing organizational, teaching, and methodological measures aimed at achieving SDG 4.3.