Abstract:Background Market-applicable concurrent electrocardiogram (ECG) diagnosis for multiple heart abnormalities that covers a wide range of arrhythmias, with better-than-human accuracy, has not yet been developed. We therefore aimed to engineer a deep learning approach for the automated multilabel diagnosis of heart rhythm or conduction abnormalities by real-time ECG analysis. Methods We used a dataset of ECGs (standard 10 s, 12-channel format) from adult patients (aged >= 18 years), with 21 distinct rhythm classes, including most types of heart rhythm or conduction abnormalities, for the diagnosis of arrhythmias at multilabel level. The ECGs were collected from three campuses of Tongji Hospital (Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan, China) and annotated by cardiologists. We used these datasets to develop a convolutional neural network approach to generate diagnoses of arrythmias. We collected a test dataset of ECGs from a new group of patients not included in the training dataset. The test dataset was annotated by consensus of a committee of board-certified, actively practicing cardiologists. To evaluate the performance of the model we assessed the F1 score and the area under the curve (AUC) of the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve, as well as quantifying sensitivity and specificity. To validate our results, findings for the test dataset were compared with diagnoses made by 53 ECG physicians working in cardiology departments who had a wide range of experience in ECG interpretation (range 0 to >12 years). An external public validation dataset of 962 ECGs from other hospitals was used to study generalisability of the diagnostic model. Findings Our training and validation dataset comprised 180 112 ECGs from 70 692 patients, collected between Jan 1, 2012, and Apr 30, 2019. The test dataset comprised 828 ECGs corresponding to 828 new patients, recorded between Sept 11, 2012, and Aug 30, 2019. At the multilabel level, our deep learning approach to diagnosing heart abnormalities resulted in an exact match in 658 (80%) of 828 ECGs, exceeding the mean performance of physicians (552 [67%] for physicians with 0-6 years of experience; 571 [69%] for physicians with 7-12 years of experience; 621 [75%] for physicians with more than 12 years of experience). Our model had an overall mean F1 score of 0 center dot 887 compared with 0 center dot 789 for physicians with 0-6 years of experience, 0 center dot 815 for physicians with 7-12 years of experience, and 0 center dot 831 for physicians with more than 12 years of experience. The model had a mean AUC ROC score of 0 center dot 983 (95% CI 0 center dot 980-0 center dot 986), sensitivity of 0 center dot 867 (0 center dot 849-0 center dot 885) and specificity of 0 center dot 995 (0 center dot 994-0 center dot 996). Promising F1 scores were also obtained from the external public database using our proposed model without any model modifications (mean F1 scores of 0 center dot 845 in multilabel and 0 center dot 852 in single-label ECGs). Interpretation Our model is more accurate than physicians working in cardiology departments at distinguishing a range of distinct arrhythmias in single-label and multilabel ECGs, laying a promising foundation for computational decision-support systems in clinical applications. Copyright (c) 2020 The Author(s). Published by Elsevier Ltd. This is an Open Access article under the CC BY-NC-ND 4.0 license.

Deep Similarity-Based Batch Mode Active Learning with Exploration-Exploitation.

HADLN: Hybrid Attention-Based Deep Learning Network for Automated Arrhythmia Classification

Deep Dynamic Patient Similarity Analysis: Model Development and Validation in ICU.

Batch Mode Active Learning and Its Application to Medical Image Classification

Multi-label Classification of Abnormalities in 12-Lead ECG Using Deep Learning.

AOCBLS: A Novel Active and Online Learning System for ECG Arrhythmia Classification with Less Labeled Samples

ASCENT: Active Supervision for Semi-Supervised Learning.

Deep Patient Similarity Learning for Personalized Healthcare.

Deep Learning Based Multi-Batch Calibration for Classification in Various Omics

BAW: Learning from Class Imbalance and Noisy Labels with Batch Adaptation Weighted Loss.

Automatic Multilabel Electrocardiogram Diagnosis of Heart Rhythm or Conduction Abnormalities with Deep Learning: a Cohort Study.

Improving Active Learning by Data Balance to Reduce Annotation Efforts

Online Co-Learning Strategy Based on Multibranch Multiscale Network for 12-Lead ECG Classification

Batch Mode Active Learning for Networked Data with Optimal Subset Selection

A Novel Myocardial Infarction Localization Method Using Multi-Branch DenseNet and Spatial Matching-Based Active Semi-Supervised Learning

Deep Learning-Based Data Augmentation and Model Fusion for Automatic Arrhythmia Identification and Classification Algorithms

Online Co-Learning Strategy Based on Multi-Branch Multi-Scale Network for 12-Lead ECG Classification

Automatic Staging Model of Heart Failure Based on Deep Learning.

Intra-Patient and Inter-Patient Multi-Classification of Severe Cardiovascular Diseases Based on CResFormer

Hierarchical deep learning for autonomous multi-label arrhythmia detection and classification on real-world wearable electrocardiogram data

Active Learning with Co-Auxiliary Learning and Multi-Level Diversity for Image Classification