Abstract:The question of which mechanical variables are responsible for inducing osteogenic activity is unresolved despite extensive experimental and theoretical investigation. Candidate variables include strain magnitude, loading frequency, the interaction of magnitude and frequency (strain rate), and strain gradients. An additional challenge is discerning the coordination of periosteal and endosteal expansion during growth, and whether this coordination (or lack thereof) is fully dependent or partially independent of the local mechanical environment. In this study, under the assumption that calculated stresses correspond to relative strain magnitudes, we specify alternative growth algorithms of bone cross-sectional size and geometry to explore skeletal growth under alternative scenarios of osteogenic activity that are tracking 1) an attractor stress, 2) local stress magnitude or 3) steepness of stress gradients. These developmental simulations are initiated from two initial geometries (symmetrical and asymmetrical ellipses) under a time-varying torsional load whose magnitude is proportional to body size growth in a model primate. In addition, we model endosteal expansion under three conditions hypothesized in the literature, in which endosteal expansion is 1) independent of the mechanical milieu, 2) completely dependent on the mechanical milieu, and 3) a "hybrid" model in which intrinsic biological (independent) growth is operative early but gives way to mechanically-sensitive (dependent) growth at later ages. Three variables were recorded over each growth simulation: the safety factor (ratio of yield stress to actual stress), an efficiency ratio (invested bone area per unit of stress), and proximity to an isostress condition (an optimal design criterion in which stress is invariant throughout the structure). The attractor stress algorithm produces the most "adapted" bones in terms of mechanical competence and economy of material. Localized osteogenic activity that is guided in direct proportion to stress magnitude produces competent bones but with variable adult geometries depending on conditions of endosteal expansion. Stress gradients also produce functional but relatively inefficient bones, with widely variable safety factors during growth and heterogeneous stress fields. If, in fact, the osteocyte network monitors strain gradients to generate osteogenic signals, the resulting morphology is competent but falls well short of an optimal mechanical solution.

Chondrocyte hypertrophy in the growth plate promotes stress anisotropy affecting long bone development through chondrocyte column formation

Regulatory Mechanism for the Proliferation and Differentiation of Growth Plates

Limited column formation in the embryonic growth plate implies divergent growth mechanisms during pre- and postnatal bone development

Part 2. Review and meta-analysis of studies on modulation of longitudinal bone growth and growth plate activity: A micro-scale perspective

Secondary ossification center induces and protects growth plate structure

Regulatory mechanisms for the development of growth plate cartilage

N-cadherin and β1 Integrin Coordinately Regulate Growth Plate Cartilage Architecture

A pathway to bone: signaling molecules and transcription factors involved in chondrocyte development and maturation

Analysis of Osteocyte Morphology in Terms of Sensation of In Vivo Stress Applied on Bone

Periodic static compression of micro-strain pattern regulates endochondral bone formation

Targeting Bone Cells During Sexual Maturation Reveals Sexually Dimorphic Regulation of Endochondral Ossification

Shape of chondrocytes within articular cartilage affects the solid but not the fluid microenvironment under unconfined compression

Growth Plate Chondrocytes: Skeletal Development, Growth and Beyond

Mechanotransduction Pathways in Cartilage

A Novel Ex Vivo Bone Culture Model for Regulation of Collagen/Apatite Preferential Orientation by Mechanical Loading

Ciliary IFT88 Protects Coordinated Adolescent Growth Plate Ossification From Disruptive Physiological Mechanical Forces

Intermittent mechanical loading on mouse tibia accelerates longitudinal bone growth by inducing PTHrP expression in the female tibial growth plate

Stiffened fibre-like microenvironment based on patterned equidistant micropillars directs chondrocyte hypertrophy

Efficacy of shear strain gradients as an osteogenic stimulus

Dynamic 3D culture: models of chondrogenesis and endochondral ossification

Chondrocyte deformation during the unloading phase of cyclic compression loading