ExCITe: A Review Of Motivating Factors For Residency And Fellowship Selection And Their Role In Advanced Heart Failure And Transplant Cardiology

Edan Zitelny,Rachna Kataria

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cardfail.2023.10.151

IF: 6.592

2024-01-01

Journal of Cardiac Failure

Abstract:Introduction Every resident or fellow has unique factors that are most crucial in guiding their career decisions. When investigating specialty selection on a system level, many fields have data suggesting core factors that motivate trainees toward career decisions. Given the annual decline of fellows pursuing Advanced Heart Failure and Transplant Cardiology (AHFTC), factors impacting this trend must be better understood to support the needs of the growing field. Methods An extensive literature review was conducted to investigate factors that residents and fellows use to decide upon a specific specialty. A total of 1469 studies were screened via PubMed. All studies designs were included, as the goal of the review was to elicit qualitative outcomes. Results A total of 103 studies from 33 specialties were assessed. The literature spanned 88 unique journals, ranging in impact factors from 0.538 to 44.54. Most publications employed a survey as their study design (81.6%, n=84), surveying over 62,530 individuals predominately in the United States (70.5%). Four predominant factors emerged and were investigated more thoroughly: early exposure to the field (52 of 103 studies, 50.4%), clinical stimulation by the field (62 of 103 studies, 59.2%), inclusion and advocacy within the field (69 of 103 studies, 66.9%), and team-based mentorship (69 of 103 studies, 66.9%). Conclusions A systematic review of 103 manuscripts was conducted investigating factors that motivate trainees to pursue certain careers. There was consistency of motivating factors across all specialties, regardless of a medical or surgical focus. Within the AHFTC community, the next step is assessing what interventions can have the most significant impact on the future of trainees pursuing the field. Based on the themes that were seen, the mnemonic “ExCITe” (Figure 1) was developed to group interventions based upon the four key categories. Using this framework, leaders in the AHFTC community can identify ways to motivate and support trainees interested in heart failure and, more broadly, cardiology. By using these interventions, the field may more successfully “catch” residents at more appropriate times in their career and retain fellows most interested in AHFTC.

cardiac & cardiovascular systems